Challenge 02 Round 01 Results

Sep 16, 2008 00:15

I'm so sorry, but we have to say "goodbye" to some participants.



Eliminated:


la_fleur_darion with 5 votes



overevery with 5 votes

People's Choice:


pursy with 4 votes

Mod's Choice:


t00tsy
For the creativity!

Did you forget your icon number? You can find it HERE

Voting Tally:

01| +3
02| -3
03| -5
04| +4
05| -1+1= 0
06| -2+3= +1
07| -2
08| -6+1= -5
09| -1
10| 0
11| -1+1= 0
12| 0
13| +1

Favourite icons
1 - this icon is just wow!
001 - Interesting icon really.
#001 - The icon is very creative. I love how the backgroung picture blends in.

4 - nice colors are cropping
004 - pretty colors and crop
004 - Good colors.
4 - mostly because of cropping, it looks handsome

5 - good colouring and cropping

6 - good texture and cropping
6 - I really love the colours! very beautiful result though light texture looks a bit strange
#006 - I love teh ocloring on Rihanna, and altough I find the light texture too much I still like this icon.

8 - gorgeous and bright colouring!

011 - textures are lovely & nice crop

13 - good cropping nad very pretty colors

Lesser quality icons
02 - colors are washed out, icon is blurry
2 - icon definitely needs more contrast and a bit sharp
#002 - The icon i stoo dark and lacks contrast.

3 - the icon is too dark
003 - the icon is too dark, and too red
003 - Too much red, need some more contrast.
3 - icon needs more contrast, it's too dark
#003 - The icon is too dark and she looks like she is having an exotic sickness because of the coloring.

005 - Pale colors, nedd some more contrast, a bit blurry.

06 - icon is blurry and texture doesn't match at all
6 - texture isn't flattering

7 - too yellow colour of her face. puzzle texture doesn't look well
007 - texture doesn't go well with the image & the background looks bad

08 - her hairs are too red and icon is oversharped
8 - the colouring is too blue and oversharpened
008 - the coloring is too pale and too red/pink
008 - Not really good colors - too much cyan, skin is too red.
8 - icon is over-saturated
#008 - The icon is oversaturated, and it is too red and pink.

9 - I guess crop isn't too lucky, cause part of face is cut off and at the left side is too much free space

11 - The texture don't fit the icon

results, round_01, challenge_02

Previous post Next post
Up