AN: I know several other fanfic writers have had a crack at this most common of missing scenes. In my opinion the_elb’s three-part fic, “These Dull Colors” is the best of them all. If you haven’t read it, check it out. Some fics say that the sword Jack threw away was his patriotic fund sword, yet he still has it in later books, so I think it was
(
Read more... )
Comments 8
Thank you so much for the compliment too, and you are completely right about the Patriotic Fund sword! I had that sword in my own fic because of Stephen's words to Sir Joseph about him valuing it, but I just looked it up and it's mentioned at least twice after. Do you mind if I go and edit mine? :D
Reply
It just seemed to be so appropriate that Jack's real name would mean something that fits so well with Stephen's perception of him. Even if POB never actually says as much himself, Jack is Stephen's savior, hence the name of the fic.
Also, back when I first wrote this, I was going to have Jack playing to Stephen on the violin for his solace, but then I read your little masterpiece and edited that part out, since I didn't want to seem like I was copying anybody else's ideas. Besides, if I had left it in, mine would have been unbelievably cheesy, and not just dramatic.
Reply
I'm sure it wouldn't have been; the rest of the fic was great, after all! Again, I enjoyed it immensely, and thank you for your kind words. :D
Reply
*smiles and rereads*
Reply
Reply
A beautiful telling of a most painful period in their story.
Reply
We learn how strongly Stephen feels for Jack - how much he feels safe with him - when after this Stephen refuses to sail with anyone else. That was POB's method.
I like how you let Stephen have his outburst, including the screaming, and listening to Jack's heartbeat. I am always amazed how well our heroes hold onto their sanity - no PTSD for them! - and I think it is this comfort they get from one another, not detailed by POB but present nonetheless, that ensures it.
Reply
Reply
Leave a comment