Round 02: Challenge 01 - Results

Jan 05, 2011 16:40

I believe we're almost back on regular schedule, so yay! and what not, anywho...

Results )

challenge 01, round 02, results

Leave a comment

Comments 7

anonymous January 5 2011, 22:00:16 UTC
coldstofcalndrs January 5 2011, 22:05:04 UTC
#05 - I like the interpretation used here and the crop is awesome
#05 - I like that the yellow color is in the background and not too forceful on the eyes. The text is fine, and the crop is creative!
#05 - Really lovely colour scheme here, the yellow isn't overbearing inthe slightest. The text placement is great, and the background textures work well together.
#05 - I love the use of coloring and texture in this icon - it suits the image nicely.

And updated logs are here if you wish to check them out

Reply


anonymous January 6 2011, 00:48:26 UTC
coldstofcalndrs January 6 2011, 02:27:20 UTC
#07 - The entire icon comes together really well; the lighter green pulls teh focus to Mukuro, then you notice the text. The text in particular is nicely done, too.
#07 - I like the cropping, and the simplicity is wonderful! The text is readable and the green shades are nice.
#07 - This one has a very nice composition and cropping. The background looks so smooth and well thought-out, and that white brush/texture behind Mukuro seems to be a wave which represents the element water. The character, though, is a tad blurry, especially at his arms, but this doesn't really stand out.
#07 - I adore the use of text in this icon, it really adds a nice touch to the icon, especially in combination with the textures.

Reply


anonymous January 6 2011, 01:01:19 UTC
coldstofcalndrs January 6 2011, 02:32:18 UTC
#01 - Hibari stands out nicely, and the way the extra representation was implemented is is subtle and unique from the rest
#01 - I like the way the green looks, it's vibrant & beautiful. The manga coloring is nice as is the kanji used for background purposes, it's all lovely.
#01 - The shade of green for this icon is almost a little too yellow and bright, but I like the overall look of the icon. Having Kanji on icons is appealing to me and I like the coloring? of the skin.

I apologize for that and have already fixed it

Reply

anonymous January 6 2011, 04:51:38 UTC
coldstofcalndrs January 6 2011, 05:15:32 UTC
it's OK to pimp again right, even though the sign up closed ? because I want to create public-pimp in my private journal..XD

You can continue to promote the community as much as you want, but since sign-ups are closed, promotions will no longer gain extra points.

Reply


anonymous January 6 2011, 04:34:38 UTC
coldstofcalndrs January 6 2011, 05:16:52 UTC
#09 - Good choice of picture to represent hard work but apart from that, the guidelines were only very loosely interpreted and could have been better included. It also is quite over-sharpened.

And don't rush next time! You make such great icons!!!

Reply


(The comment has been removed)

coldstofcalndrs January 6 2011, 20:44:53 UTC
#02 - It is amazing how the iconmaker managed to fit in all the guidelines. The icon is very red, which represents the element fire very well, but the white colour in the flame balances out everything wonderfully. The text, though, could have been better placed - it nearly "slices" Tsuna's throat.
#02 - I really enjoy the colours you've got here, the deep reds contrast nicely against the bright flame .
#02 - This is such a fantastic icon, but the text is unnecessary. It takes away from all of the depth you created with the colours.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up