Comments | razorbacklane: American Idol Top 8... Queen Night/ Questions about Real World Key West

razorbacklane

American Idol Top 8... Queen Night/ Questions about Real World Key West

Apr 11, 2006 22:01

I think for the most part this episode was a lot better than I had expected. Here is how I rank their performances from tonight ( Read more... )

Comments 11

ex_nomoresci293 April 12 2006, 06:24:21 UTC

I really enjoyed paris last night. I loved her look and her song choice. She reminded me of when I saw Janet Jackson live performing that song 'Black Cat.'

I think Ace might go tonight.

razorbacklane April 12 2006, 08:23:11 UTC

I think you are right. I don't think he is the one that should go home but he hasn't been as good since the top 12 was named as he was before that point. I just hope we don't lose another good one like we did last week.

ex_nomoresci293 April 12 2006, 10:16:51 UTC

I'm afraid for Taylor tonight... even though I think it will be Ace that goes.

razorbacklane April 13 2006, 06:15:38 UTC

Bye bye Bucky you said? ;) I also thought Taylor might be in the bottom 3 and knew Ace would be.

Thread 5

chicklitter April 12 2006, 06:45:38 UTC

I actually thought Elliot was the best. And what was up with Chris' eye liner? Although the scruffy beard look he was rocking was freaking hot. Musically, though, I thought he did a good job, although I kinda agreed with Randy and Simon--this could have and should have been his "moment." Then again, I respect the fact that he didn't want to do something that had already been done. Taylor, Katherine and Paris also did a good job, although something about Paris still irks me. And I completely agree with your bottom three. :-)

razorbacklane April 12 2006, 08:25:26 UTC

Elliott was really awesome last night. Chris' eye liner was not cute. He was looking SUPER sexy last night. I am glad we are on the same page on the bottom 3!!! Great minds think alike!

chicklitter April 12 2006, 09:20:08 UTC

I really like Elliott and I hope he stays for a while. I don't think he'll win, but he has a great voice. Yeah, Chris should ditch the eyeliner, but keep the scruffy beard look. HAWT~! *grin*

And of course great minds think alike. :-)

razorbacklane April 12 2006, 14:40:19 UTC

Yeah my top 3 right now overall are Elliott, Chris, and Paris.

dixidiamond April 12 2006, 22:17:15 UTC

I am totally heartbroken that Bucky went home. I know that you absolutely do not agree with me, but I LOVE the fact that he always Bucky-izes the songs. Unlike Ace (beautiful but can't sing unless it's in falsetto) or Pickler, he actually has some natural talent. Elliot can sing like a bird, but he bores me to tears. Paris is good. Katherine sings everything exactly like it's been done before. Chris has a lot of talent, but already his ego way exceeds that. Yes, more than likely, this will be the next American Idol. Taylor is unique, and I'm curious to see what he's going to do next. I guess I will never be able to cheer for the American Idol again (I did cheer on Kelly Clarkson...she was the only one I was able to pick because I knew there was something less poppy and amazing about her.)because I just don't like the performers who conform to that standard.

BTW- did you know that Pickler is Vote For The Worst's candidate this year?

razorbacklane April 13 2006, 06:14:42 UTC

I figured you would be upset. I totally disagree with you just about everything else you said about the other people on the show but hey it's cool. That is what I love about you and I we are not afraid to speak our minds to each other and know that it won't offend the other one. ;)

I think Kellie is the weakest one left and yes I knew she was the one that they are trying to vote for pick the worst. I am afriad some good people will go home before she does and that is unfair but life is unfair so we move on I guess. Have a good day and love and miss ya.