I personally went with D, but B is hilarious...
Suppose your friend says to you, "She says that she loves me and she must be telling the truth, because she certainly wouldn't lie to someone that she loves." Which of the following would be a logically justified response to what your friend said?
a. "That makes sense to me! Better propose soon while she still loves you."
b. "I hate to have to tell you this, but your argument actually supports the conclusion that she must be lying to you."
c. "I hate to have to tell you this, but your argument actually supports the conclusion that she does not love you at all."
d. "Slow down there, friend. While it may be so that she is telling you the truth, your argument doesn't establish that she must be telling the truth."
a. "That makes sense to me! Better propose soon while she still loves you."
b. "I hate to have to tell you this, but your argument actually supports the conclusion that she must be lying to you."
c. "I hate to have to tell you this, but your argument actually supports the conclusion that she does not love you at all."
d. "Slow down there, friend. While it may be so that she is telling you the truth, your argument doesn't establish that she must be telling the truth."