Here are the results for Round 3, Challenge 1.
ELIMINATED:
By
monsterxpants.
I don't understand it. I loved your icon! I'm so sorry to see you go so soon :(.
PEOPLE'S CHOICE:
By
fanplastico. [
BANNER ]
MOD'S CHOICE:
By
harrypotterchic. [
BANNER ]
BANNERS ARE NOT ONLINE RIGHT NOW, I'LL UPLOAD THEM ASAP
TALLIES:
01. +3 -1 = +2
02. -2
03. +1 -1 = 0
04. -4
05. +2 -1 = +1
06. -3
Comments:
01:
- The crop is really cool, but Dan seems really red
+ really nice colouring and cropping
+ The coloring and cropping are beautiful, and I love the duplication of the picture. His eyes look so nice! :)
+ NO COMMENT
02:
- The coloring is too red, and not enough detail is distinguishable.
- the image is oversharpened and the contrast is too extreme. Yet at the same time its hard to tell who the icon is of...
03:
- There's more emphasis on the texture than the subject of the icon.
+ Lovely coloring and crop!
04:
- the texture doesn't really fit the image
- the icon isn't eyecatching, and looks dirty
- The base/texture in the background makes the icon look dark, and the cap is blurry. Also, the light texture near Dan's left (or right, from his perspective) arm doesn't really fit.
- The background doesn't accent the icon.
05:
- the b/w is really dull in contrast with the texture
+ NO COMMENT
+ Nice blending :)
06:
- The black and white isn't dark enough.
- The cropping is nice, but since the picture was taken in daylight, it doesn't look good in black and white. Also, the texture at the bottom has a negative effect on the icon as a whole.
- the text is too hard to read. The image is a bit oversharpened and the crop should be a bit tighter and more centered.
Challenge 2 will be post in a few minutes.