XVI, by Julia Karr

May 31, 2011 07:50

I would never be a crazed sex-teen!Someone could write a good teen dystopia based on the screwed-up messages that modern American society sends to teenage girls: If you have sex with boys, you’re a slut. If you don’t, you’re a prude, a lesbian, or a reject. If you dress fashionably, you’re a slut. If you dress conservatively, you’re a prude. If you ( Read more... )

genre: implausible plots, awesomely bad books, genre: young adult, genre: and now i preach at you, read-a-thon, author: karr julia, genre: science fiction, genre: organized dystopia

Leave a comment

(The comment has been removed)

rachelmanija May 31 2011, 18:12:49 UTC
I think readers tend to have lines they draw in the sand, and if a character steps over them it's straight into the Moral Event Horizon. Infidelity is a common one. Despising your own friends is one of mine. (Luckily, that comes up less than infidelity.)

Note that both share elements of hurting the ones you (supposedly) love, and of humiliation squick.

Reply

(The comment has been removed)

kateelliott May 31 2011, 23:07:08 UTC
ambyr May 31 2011, 18:41:45 UTC
Despising your own friends is one of mine.

I'm not sure I've ever seen it put so clearly; thanks. That was one of my central problems with Who Fears Death, for another example.

Reply

asakiyume May 31 2011, 19:53:32 UTC
I'm with you and Janni and Ambyr. That's not any sort of friendship I'd ever want to experience.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up