I have extreme difficulties seeing many of your actions with Yuki as IC. Asking Taro and L to kill him just because Aaya showed up? Assuming, with absolutely no evidence, that a "perfectly ordinary sheep" killed by Excel was Hiro when there have been other sheep in the camp? And, presumably, Tohru is still wearing the Hirosweater? Asking in Mello's memorial post for L, "So what was his opinion of justice?" 1) ...why? 2) HUGE picture of L at the top of the post what says "Justice will prevail!"
As for the sheep, I never saw any other posts that mentioned normal sheep at camp, other than T-zou. (Who... well, isn't normal anyway.) That, and Excel had directly tried to kill Hiro!Sheep before (or at least talked about it), and Yuki had to move in to distract her.
And... really, saying "justice will prevail" and what justice actually is are two different things. The latter was what Yuki was asking. (Yuki looked up to L, and thought knowing that would help him appreciate his memory. For a person who's a detective and does say things like 'Justice will prevail!', can you really disagree?)
Well, thank you for being honest, and for providing concrete examples.
And the Hirosweater? And there have been other sheep. A few were killed for blood along with goats; Lee had a pet sheep for a bit, until it too got killed in hopes of saving lives from the tenth plague. Presumably more sheep could be found somewhere.
It is inferrable, that when someone is smiling like that and saying "Justice will prevail!" it means they have a positive view of justice, that they believe justice is a good thing.
When did Yuki and L ever really talk before L died, for Yuki to look up to him?
Tohru has been male for the past few days, when she's posted... the Hiro-sweater hasn't really meen mentioned (Mostly because Hiro-rper quit and we don't really want to give the impression he's still at camp, and could show up as human anytime).
...but that still doesn't say what justice is. You can point at a house and say: "That's a house," but you can't do that with justice. (And really... who would say: "I don't like justice."? Raito thinks what he does is justice, because he thinks he's creating a new world free of crime
( ... )
Personally, I enjoy your Yuki and I've done my best hunting his threads through the archives. I like him enough that I've apped as Haru this time around, and I definitely wouldn't do that if I disliked the Yuki haru's supposed to look up to and want to take care of.
I think the other anon makes some good points, yeah, but I think you've got a good enough grasp on Yuki that you can easily make him IC again. :)
However, just because it hasn't been mentioned, it doesn't mean that it doesn't exist.
If you really care to find out what a dead person thought of justice, is asking one of his bereaved at the funeral really the best thing? Yuki's not that bad with people. Why would Yuki care to debate justice from the deceased L's point of view with Mello? No, really?
I have extreme difficulties seeing many of your actions with Yuki as IC. Asking Taro and L to kill him just because Aaya showed up? Assuming, with absolutely no evidence, that a "perfectly ordinary sheep" killed by Excel was Hiro when there have been other sheep in the camp? And, presumably, Tohru is still wearing the Hirosweater? Asking in Mello's memorial post for L, "So what was his opinion of justice?" 1) ...why? 2) HUGE picture of L at the top of the post what says "Justice will prevail!"
I don't see it, and I don't like it.
Reply
You may have a point about Taro and L.
As for the sheep, I never saw any other posts that mentioned normal sheep at camp, other than T-zou. (Who... well, isn't normal anyway.) That, and Excel had directly tried to kill Hiro!Sheep before (or at least talked about it), and Yuki had to move in to distract her.
And... really, saying "justice will prevail" and what justice actually is are two different things. The latter was what Yuki was asking. (Yuki looked up to L, and thought knowing that would help him appreciate his memory. For a person who's a detective and does say things like 'Justice will prevail!', can you really disagree?)
Well, thank you for being honest, and for providing concrete examples.
Reply
It is inferrable, that when someone is smiling like that and saying "Justice will prevail!" it means they have a positive view of justice, that they believe justice is a good thing.
When did Yuki and L ever really talk before L died, for Yuki to look up to him?
Reply
...but that still doesn't say what justice is. You can point at a house and say: "That's a house," but you can't do that with justice. (And really... who would say: "I don't like justice."? Raito thinks what he does is justice, because he thinks he's creating a new world free of crime ( ... )
Reply
I think the other anon makes some good points, yeah, but I think you've got a good enough grasp on Yuki that you can easily make him IC again. :)
- Different Anon!
Reply
Reply
If you really care to find out what a dead person thought of justice, is asking one of his bereaved at the funeral really the best thing? Yuki's not that bad with people. Why would Yuki care to debate justice from the deceased L's point of view with Mello? No, really?
Reply
I don't think I was expecting anyone to be mad.
Reply
Leave a comment