Radiohead: are they any good?

Jan 07, 2011 12:11

Today I shall be mostly listening to Radiohead, in an attempt to find out if they're as bad as I remember ( Read more... )

music, school, rants

Leave a comment

andrewducker January 7 2011, 12:41:13 UTC
I've been a massive fan of Radiohead (I listened to The Bends a _lot_), but not so much of their more recent stuff. I'm looking forward to hearing what you think.

Reply

pozorvlak January 7 2011, 13:08:00 UTC
I'm getting a big split between fans of early and late Radiohead here. Interesting.

Reply

andrewducker January 7 2011, 13:18:19 UTC
Yeah, OK Computer was the changnig point - where they went from Rock (with some electronica) to Electronica (with some rock). Which is why that album is popular with both groups, but the ones either side of that line tend to put off one of the groups.

Reply

pozorvlak January 7 2011, 13:21:38 UTC
That certainly fits with aftnn.org - a big electronica fan - only liking their later stuff. But as a fan of both rock and electronica, I might even enjoy all of it :-)

Reply

ext_30864 January 7 2011, 21:10:31 UTC
I would categorise their early stuff as indie. I like rock, but I'm not a big fan of indie.

Reply

pozorvlak January 7 2011, 21:16:24 UTC
Pablo Honey had rocky moments, but overall I agree.

Reply

pozorvlak January 7 2011, 13:27:50 UTC
So far, though, the guitarist is hands-down the best thing about the group. I'll need some convincing that moving to a less guitar-heavy sound was a good move for them...

Reply

andrewducker January 7 2011, 14:45:15 UTC
I'm going to have to have a listen myself over the weekend now!

Reply

penumbra January 7 2011, 15:37:58 UTC
He is a multi-instrumentalist and composer/arranger.

Reply

pozorvlak January 7 2011, 15:47:20 UTC
That doesn't surprise me. OK, let me re-phrase: the best thing about their sound in Pablo Honey (and, come to that, at least as far as half-way through OK Computer) was the guitar.

Reply

penumbra January 7 2011, 22:00:33 UTC
I really meant that you had no reason to fear instrumental incompetency -- I didn't mean to correct you re: vocabulary (that would have been a ridiculous nitpick, especially since I'm sure he would refer to himself as "the [lead] guitarist" or "a guitarist").

Reply

pozorvlak January 7 2011, 22:25:43 UTC
Oh, I see. I wasn't really sure what you were getting at there: thanks for explaining.

Reply

pozorvlak January 7 2011, 20:28:13 UTC
*reads Wikipedia some more*

I see that they have three guitarists, at least two of whom have been rated among the best in the modern era in polls (polls of whom, I can't be bothered to check right now).

Reply

penumbra January 7 2011, 21:58:38 UTC
I assumed you were referring to Jonny Greenwood; he plays lead. He does consistently end up on those kinds of lists. (He also wrote the score for There Will Be Blood.)

Reply


Leave a comment

Up