(Untitled)

Aug 13, 2012 21:29

Here is the last day.
TITLE: Wands and Winx
PERPETRATOR: Akela Victoire
SUE-O-METER:
Read more... )

sue - lily luna potter, rating - awful, pf - new/next generation, p - crossover

Leave a comment

Comments 21

sapnish August 14 2012, 15:57:12 UTC
"You know who I am already. I'm Mariah Hollins and I hail from the land down under, also known as AUSTRALIA!" Mariah cheered.
(...)
"I go by the name of Felicia Chen and you can probably tell by the accent that I'm from Jamaica.(...)"
(...)
The Latina girl spoke next with a Spanish accent behind her words. "I am Liliana Perez. I come from Bolivia."
(...)
"Nothing like this in Israel, that's for sure…" I utterly hate this...feature...that amateur writers have of keep reminding us where is the character from and using it as a way of keeping the character flat, as if it was the intro of the freaking Captain Planet. How many great stories have been made without verbally revealing the character's birthplace, or where the story is set, just because the argument is well thought and the narrative is fluent ( ... )

Reply

darth_gojira August 14 2012, 16:51:34 UTC
I'm so annoyed by these kinds of flat stereotypes. IN AMERICA!

Actually my first reaction was being reminded of that MST3k episode with "12 to the Moon"

Reply

yemi_hikari August 14 2012, 19:37:26 UTC
Could you possibly elaborate for those of us not familiar with the episode?

Reply

darth_gojira August 14 2012, 20:06:25 UTC
It featured an international crew going into space, each one of them a stereotype that kept on reminding the audience on their nationality. The hero? A studly American. The villain? A weasley French. The red herring villain? Russian. The first to die, and a pompous prideful old scientist? British. The main conflict was between an Israeli and his mentor, who was secretly the son of a Nazi.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J7auiDXqY_w&feature=related

Reply


yemi_hikari August 14 2012, 20:32:32 UTC
I don't remember anywhere that it says that a fairy's first transformation is based on emotional reasons. I even tried confirming this with the wiki for Winx club. A girl can either be trained to become a Witch or a Fairy, so it isn't as simple as that. Case in point is Mirta, who starts off as a Witch and transfers to Alfea so she can learn to be a Fairy instead. I also have to wonder if someone can become a Fairy without knowing what a Fairy is or believing in them ( ... )

Reply


anonymous August 24 2012, 02:29:43 UTC
What;s so wrong with the character? The story barely started. You didn't even give this author a chance to get the character(s) developed properly...

Reply


ext_1366353 August 24 2012, 02:42:24 UTC
Are you freaking kidding me? ANOTHER obnoxious, snarky "let's tear down someone else's fanfiction because we're obviously experts who know the cannon and characters better than anyone else" site? Ugh

Writers WRITE. Writers create. Writers sometimes make mistakes, yes, which is why we have beta readers and the ability to leave reviews and make suggestions.

These kinds of sites do nothing but tear down others' hard work. And you're attacking from the anonymity of the internet, which makes it an even more childish and cowardly act. I bet your mothers are all very proud. :-p

Reply

castleofcolours August 25 2012, 03:50:23 UTC
Actually my mother is very proud of my courage. I am in the army afterall.

It is like I said before, this is not the purpose of this journal. I am quite positive that if you go to faqs or search around on another page, you will find a mission statement of some sort.

"let's tear down someone else's fanfiction because we're obviously experts who know the cannon and characters better than anyone else"

Actually, no... no it isn't. See above above.

For argument's sake let us take this to a PM.

Reply


lovelovelovix August 24 2012, 02:49:22 UTC
Anon's right. You can't expect something to work this easily when it is this new. Especially crossovers. Until the verse is truly explored, and the connection between verses established, there is practically no way to tell how a character is going to work in the verse. So many known stories explore multitalents; why can't this one? If you didn't concentrate on the character who had something special, you wouldn't have a story ( ... )

Reply


Leave a comment

Up