Leave a comment

Comments 45

indigoneutrino June 28 2012, 09:53:52 UTC
Typical tagalong, copycat, plagiarised Harry's twin fic. The only thing marginally original about this is that the Sue has annoying Sue friends.

Reply

yemi_hikari June 28 2012, 19:58:53 UTC
Agreed.

Reply


sapnish June 28 2012, 12:10:41 UTC
I'm tired of people doing this, which is why I'm going to openly mock them:

"Dobby, Patsy and Kiki -no- HELP!" Harry bellowed toward the cottage, toward the people moving there "HELP!"

He did not know or care wether they were wizards or muggles, friends or foes; all that he cared about was that three dark stains were spreading across Dobby's, Patsy's and Kiki's fronts and that they had stretched out their thin arms to Harry with looks of supplication. Harry caught them and laid them sideways on the cool grass.

"Dobby, Patsy and Kiki, no, don't die, don't die-"

All of the elves's eyes found him, and all of their lips trembled with the effort to form words.

"Harry...Potter..."

And then with three little shudders the elves became quite still, and their eyes were nothing more than great glossy orbs, sprinkled with light from the stars they could not see.

Dammit, I'm such a genius.

Reply

sandstorm June 28 2012, 13:25:53 UTC
I didn't read your first sentence, so I was like "Don't tell me this author doesn't know what's in what book!"

Reply

yemi_hikari June 28 2012, 20:00:12 UTC
I bet it only took you very little time to write this too. Lol.

Reply

sapnish June 28 2012, 20:25:08 UTC
It took me more to decide what to rip off than anything else :D

Reply


darth_gojira June 28 2012, 14:14:28 UTC
Wow, they combined two terrible fic cliches: insertions of Harry's sister who just tags along, and the flood of interchangeable self-insertions
It's still horribly boring

Reply


grendelmere June 28 2012, 19:04:16 UTC
"I did feel sorry for Mrs. Figg but I couldn't stand another year in her cabbage smelling house"

Holy crap, Dudley's birthday outings are long. A whole year?

Does anyone remember an old episode of Torchwood involving an alien which survived by inserting itself into people's memories? I think Sues like this might be the same. They survive by latching on to an existing story. Then they just sit there, existing.

Reply

indigoneutrino June 28 2012, 19:19:45 UTC
They're Parasite Sues - they attach themselves to Harry and try to gain attention by detracting from all his experiences and achievements through their own involvement in them. Completely boring and unoriginal. There are some Sues I love because I find them so bad it's funny, but this kind I can't stand.

Reply

yemi_hikari June 28 2012, 20:01:10 UTC
Parasites are a good way to describe this type of Sue.

Reply

pottersues June 29 2012, 06:39:33 UTC
I think I want to use this as a possible tag... it fits so well. Is that all right with you?

Reply


beacon80 June 28 2012, 19:38:50 UTC
Ugh, pick up the pace. While I usually don't mind fics that take their time (my own abandoned fic was 5 chapters in and Harry was still at Number Four), those fics are ideally taking their time to show me something I haven't seen before.
If nothing's going to change until they get to school, you could skim over things a bit.

Reply

yemi_hikari June 28 2012, 20:02:19 UTC
That's what I do with my stories that are similar to the original plot line. I skim over the stuff that is the same. Then again, one of the reasons I do it is because I'm against plagiarism like I am and I understand not skimming over it constitutes plagiarism.

Reply

darth_gojira June 28 2012, 22:18:48 UTC
This is why I hate these "insert character into storyline" fics-they make an unnecessary character than is entirely pointless. It's boring, it's not original at all, and it's just pointless.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up