5126: Kunoichi at Hogwarts - Naruto "Nara" Uzumaki

[pottersues]

The third most popular fandom to cross over with Harry Potter on the pit is Naruto. There are over 2.6k crossovers for the two fandom.
⚡

Title: Kunoichi at Hogwarts

Perpetrator: Amaterasu53

Sue-O-Meter: Toxic

Cover/Banner Art: It's a picture of Hogwarts castle.

Summary: “Naru doesn't know how she landed in a country or school she's never heard of with

Comments

[anonymous]

Okay, I am going to be honest here: I love, love, love the bit where "Naruto" winds up with a big ol' toad that rides around on her head. That seems simultaneously very Naruto and very Harry Potter, even if it is a ripoff of Kiba and Akamaru. The mental image a cute blonde witch going about with a big fat toad on her head, the toad being so happy to have been adopted...it delights me (even though I'm imagining a Trevor-like toad, and I'm guessing the writer probably meant one of those talking ones from Naruto).

That being said: What is the point of this being a crossover? I was a big fan of Naruto back when I was a teenager (having given it up before it ended), and even then, I think if I wanted to read a Harry Potter and Naruto crossover, I would want to see Naruto at Hogwarts, or Shikamaru or Kakashi or Sakura--my point being, making Naruto a girl and changing this much about him really makes this cease to be a crossover. It's just a Harry Potter fan fiction where the writer stole some aspects of the Naruto universe to give to their OC. So as a Naruto fan, I wouldn't read it, and as a Harry Potter-only fan, I wouldn't be interested in a Naruto crossover to begin with. I mean, reviews aren't everything, and if the writer just wants to write for passion's sake, then I say go for it. As an outside viewer, it just seems pointless to me.

[anonymous]

I'm sorry. I had two more points I wanted to make:

1) There's an entire fox tail in her wand? Poor fox! Or fern, as may be the case. 16 inches also sounds terribly unwieldy. I'd be afraid of knocking someone in the head waving that thing around during close-quarters battle.

2) Assuming that all of the Naruto story happened prior to this, Minato still being alive makes a few things that happened in that...um...how do I say this...Impossible?