Beyond Cliché

May 24, 2005 19:42

I have one word that have moved beyond cliché in my mind, SMIRK. Please, for the love of all that you hold dear, do not have everyone in the Wizarding World smirk. Sure Snape may do it on occasion, but some authors aren't happy with that. They will have Snape do it constantly, as well as both Harry and/or Draco. In fact they will all do it in the ( Read more... )

writing gaffes

Leave a comment

Comments 24

atalantapendrag May 25 2005, 00:03:59 UTC
"Snarky" is a good word in some contexts, but I can't see any HP characters using it, ever.

Reply

caseylane May 25 2005, 02:30:39 UTC
The word on occasion is fine, it's the over use that drives me crazy.

Reply

lexin May 25 2005, 11:13:26 UTC
I can't, either. But that's at least partly because it's not a word in common usage in the area of Britain I live in.

Reply

atalantapendrag May 25 2005, 16:29:07 UTC
Until very, very recently I'd only seen it online.

Reply


conuly May 25 2005, 00:15:40 UTC
What about "waspishly", JKR's adverb of choice?

Reply

caseylane May 25 2005, 02:32:49 UTC
I think because she's only written one book every few years it's fine. When I read 3 fic and 2 of them can't have Snape so much as walk into the great hall without smirking. It's way overdone, IMO.

Reply


(The comment has been removed)

zambonigirl May 25 2005, 02:52:04 UTC
I think you can put "smirking teh smirky smirk" into your interests, and it'll have a long list of other people who have that in their interests as well...

Reply


allassein May 25 2005, 00:27:18 UTC
"Eleventy one points from Gryffindor for looking at me, Potter!" Snape hissed snarkily, smirking a smirky smirk as he swooped off, batlike.

Reply

issyadore May 25 2005, 00:57:22 UTC
hehehehehe classic.

Reply

mmyrtle May 25 2005, 01:18:00 UTC
Heee -- and your icon is ever so snarky.

Reply

allassein May 25 2005, 01:20:50 UTC
How can you not love a badger sticking its tongue out at you?

Reply


mctabby May 25 2005, 01:39:46 UTC
For your smirkish reference, pleasure, and convenience: the complete list of canon smirks. :D

*flees, smirking*

Reply

caseylane May 25 2005, 02:50:35 UTC
Considering I've seen that many smirks in a 30 page story I guess Jo isn't too bad. Still OotP had a lot more than I thought.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up