Session 1 Challenge 1 Results

[loving_w]

Eliminated:


with -6
sjlnechnaia
Thanks for participating! Hope to see you next round!)

People's choice:


with +6
quiddity_
banner

lapine29's choice:


creekfan78
banner
love the style and texture use!

loving_w's choice:


supc4ik
banner
Love the crop!

Congrats!

Tallies:
1+++
2--+
3+++++
4+
5--
6++++++
7--+----
8--+-----
9-++
10--

#1
+#001 - great use of textures
+#01 - nice textures use
+#01 - soft colours looked amazing
#2
-#02 - 'cause very simply
-#02 - blurry and too simple
+#02 - very clean, simple icon that really conveys the beauty of natalie.
#3
+#03 - Good cropping.
+#03 - Nice coloring + crop. And texture use looks great
+#03 - beautiful coloring, lovely crop
+#003 - lovely texture use
+#03- great color and light textures!
#4
+#04 - i don't really like the text/font use and placement, but the black and white and texture use is very nice.
#5
-#05 - very grainy. the font doesn't match the theme of the icon very well.
-#05 - Grainy image and distracting background.
#6
+#06 - Nice texture use.
+#06 - simple, but nice looking icon
+#06 - great crop!
+#06 - blurry, but nice composition and texture use
+#006 - very nice coloring
+#06 - amazing color and crop! This icon is perfect.
#7
-#07 - Oversharpned.
-#07 - Weird crop, and texture + text doesn't fit
+#007 - like style and coloring
-#07 - bad crop and too sharpened
-#07 - oversharpened
-#007 - oversharp and overcontrasted; the crop is a bit too
-#07 - bad crop and color
#8
-#08 - Looks very original, but coloring is too bright and light textures makes it too much.
-#008 - bad use of light texture
+08 - 'cause is unusual
-#08 - this light texture doesn't fit the icon
-#08 - light texture looked inappropriate
-#008 - overcontrasted; the light spot in the center is way too big and overpowers the actual subject of the icon
-#08 - the light texture is very overpowering. it seems to be the focus more than natalie.
-#08- bad light texture
#9
-#009 - coloring is too pale
+#09 - nice colors, crop and texture =)
+#09 - good colours
#10
-#10 - 'cause blur and i don't like this coloring
-#10 - too pale colours