Leave a comment

please stay with SFPA! ext_2083957 July 27 2013, 01:29:17 UTC
Hi Samantha,
I, too, thought the Rhysling book was weird especially the bizarre decision to list authors by first name--something my students in bonehead English would do, but not what I expect from a professional. It does bother me that, possibly, I might not be making the best decisions when voting on the poems based on their versions in the antho, although I think I know a typo when I see one and would not hold it against the author, so why tell people not to buy the Rhysling antho? What possible good could come of this? Do you also tell people not to buy your novels, because believe me, the books I've had published have far more errors than any poetry I've every published anywhere courtesy of the big-time, professional publishers who inserted errors AFTER I had proofed the galleys. That's the way it is in the publishing world, really! I know you're hurt, and there's no excuse for what happened, but please don't take it out on the rest of us in SFPA. We love you and want the best for you and all of us in genre poetry. Also, remember that the people doing this are volunteers. When I was a literary agent, I could not get ANYONE to volunteer as an intern who was not an alcoholic, drug addict, illiterate, or simply unreliable. That's how it is nowadays and we're lucky anyone would volunteer to do the job.
Yours,
Denise Dumars

Reply

Re: please stay with SFPA! popelizbet July 27 2013, 02:10:39 UTC
I'm not Samantha. My name is Elizabeth R. McClellan. I stand by my statements and my assessment of the situation. If the Samantha you intended to address was Ms. Henderson, it's a bit late to ask her to stay with SFPA, since she's already resigned. And while I interned in a different field, I was none of those things when interning. As for the volunteer aspect, see my comments to Ms. Bergmann above.

Reply

Re: please stay with SFPA! samhenderson July 27 2013, 08:53:54 UTC
Hi Denise!

I'm really confused. This is Elizabeth's journal. Did you mean to respond to her?

To clarify, I have left the SFPA, but not because of the Rhysling anthology.

-Sam

Reply

Re: please stay with SFPA! popelizbet August 14 2013, 13:28:23 UTC
If you're going to call me a "Philistine", Ms. Dumars, you ought to have the decency to do it where the world can see you.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up