alternative title

Apr 18, 2010 23:39

Is it still Alternative History when a story makes no substantive changes to known historical record but imagines what might have occurred beyond the point where no definitive record exists? Or is that something else? E.g. Agatha Christie's missing days could be explored speculatively without divergence from existing history.

Leave a comment

Comments 10

drasecretcampus April 18 2010, 22:54:34 UTC
fictional history? Speculative history. Faction, even. Much of,say, the last days of Hitler in the bunker.

Reply

pigeonhed April 18 2010, 23:11:51 UTC
The case in point is Lewis Shiner's Perfidia which speculates on how Glenn Miller may have died.
Secret history?

Reply


del_c April 18 2010, 23:28:50 UTC
The taxonomy I saw on soc.history.what-if in the old days called that Secret History: history we don't know about.

Reply

gummitch April 19 2010, 07:10:44 UTC
Yep. This.

Reply

sbisson April 19 2010, 08:28:51 UTC
Yes, that's the term. Stories like Dan Simmons' The Terror or Drood.

Reply


stevegreen April 19 2010, 02:50:22 UTC
It can't be 'alternative history' if there's no fixed history for it to represent an alternative to.

Reply


anonymous April 19 2010, 04:01:43 UTC
ビーダーマイヤー買います!

Reply


secritcrush April 19 2010, 04:58:00 UTC
Secret History.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up