Robin's gifts are all handmade and appear to have been made in the Arts & Crafts hut. They come with a hand-written note with Robin's name on each. If your name is not on this list and you're an acquaintance of Robin's, you still probably got a handmade card wishing you Merry Christmas and Happy New Year.
Sera - A
Paper Christmas Tree, about a foot tall, with little cookie/pie/cake-shaped paper ornaments and tiny orange "lights" on a string
Nana - A tin of sugar cookies in the shape of music notes and microphones (they are slightly misshapen in places, but it's obvious Robin worked very hard to get them to come out right)
Abel - A tin of gingerbread men cookies and a note thanking him for letting her stay in the chapel
Vincent - A set of three handmade candles that have been dyed red, blue, and green and have gold and silver glitter inlaid in the wax
Sam - A hand-sewn medicine bag with a tiny piece of Malachite inside, and a tin of chocolate mint cookies shaped like Christmas trees
Dean - A hand-painted coffee mug with a panorama of Dean and Sam and the Impala in the sunset, and a tin of sugar cookies shaped like snowflakes
Kaname - A handknit scarf in black and crimson with swirling patterns as well as his name embroidered on it
Yuuki - A handknit scarf in white and indigo with star patterns as well as her name embroidered on it
Zero - A handknit scarf in blue and black with crescent moon patterns as well as his name embroidered on it
Mullin - An illustrated storybook collection for children, containing some of Robin's favorites: Alice in Wonderland, Ali Baba & The Forty Thieves, Rikki-Tikki-Tavi, and a lot more
Ryoji - A homemade pecan pie
Konatsu - A hand-painted coffee mug with patterns of little beavers on it, and an Italian Roast coffee blend