Round Two; Challenge Five Voting
Welcome to voting post! Please follow the directions carefully and exactly or your vote will be discounted. Voting is open to everyone and anyone, including contestants who are no longer participating.
dark_branwen has chosen to use their skip chance this week.
The following participants have failed to submit and have previously used their skip chance, thus eliminated from this round: teh_maskmaid.
Rules
[*] Underneath the cut, you will find 04 icons. You need to choose ONE icon of the least quality. Do not vote for any other factors aside from the overall quality of the icon or it will defeat the purpose of the contest. Consider the icon's technical aspects - cropping, coloring, image quality, etc - rather than your personal prefereneces.
[*] Give a reason for why you feel these icon is lesser quality. This will help participants improve for the future. It doesn't have to be lengthy, but it must be valid. Eg. The texture is distracting from the subject of the icon.
[*] Then, you must choose the icon you feel is of the highest quality. Once again, this does not mean that you pick the icon that is your favorite or one that you would use because of its style, subject, etc. Consider the technical aspects only.
[*] Also give a reason for why you feel that icon is of the highest quality. This will let iconners know what they are doing right and makes everyone feel warm and fuzzy inside.
[*] Do not vote for your icon.
01
02
03
04
dark_branwen has chosen to use their skip chance this week.
The following participants have failed to submit and have previously used their skip chance, thus eliminated from this round: teh_maskmaid.
Rules
[*] Underneath the cut, you will find 04 icons. You need to choose ONE icon of the least quality. Do not vote for any other factors aside from the overall quality of the icon or it will defeat the purpose of the contest. Consider the icon's technical aspects - cropping, coloring, image quality, etc - rather than your personal prefereneces.
[*] Give a reason for why you feel these icon is lesser quality. This will help participants improve for the future. It doesn't have to be lengthy, but it must be valid. Eg. The texture is distracting from the subject of the icon.
[*] Then, you must choose the icon you feel is of the highest quality. Once again, this does not mean that you pick the icon that is your favorite or one that you would use because of its style, subject, etc. Consider the technical aspects only.
[*] Also give a reason for why you feel that icon is of the highest quality. This will let iconners know what they are doing right and makes everyone feel warm and fuzzy inside.
[*] Do not vote for your icon.
01
02
03
04