Alternatives: New Beginnings (1/2)

Nov 09, 2008 11:37

Who_Daily Link: < a href="http://persiflage-1.livejournal.com/185085.html">Alternatives: New Beginnings (1/2) by < lj user=persiflage_1> (Characters: Human-Ten, Alt-Martha, Rose, Tyler family | Rating: PG-13 | Spoilers: Seasons 2 - 4 ( Read more... )

character: rose tyler, characters: tyler family, character: alt-martha, series: alternatives, character: human-doctor, fic: au

Leave a comment

radiantbaby November 10 2008, 13:21:40 UTC
Handy + alt!Martha = PURE WIN!

This was really good and I can't wait to read more. Rose is admittedly a bit OTT in this, but then, isn't she always? I always felt so bad for Handy in JE when, just after kissing him, she ran after the dematerializing TARDIS. I knew it could only really go downhill from there. I mean, yes, Handy looks like the Doctor, but he isn't -- he's some weird amalgam of the Doctor, Donna, and his own self. I hate stories that forget about that aspect of himself and I am glad that you didn't shy away from the inherent inner struggle that poor guy must have. I can only imagine that would make his relationships really difficult -- especially if Rose is expecting some sort of carbon-copy of the Doctor to grow old with (which honestly, that also assumes he hasn't had any emotional growth since she left, but with the exception of the weird reset-ness of the finales, he has changed -- which is honestly part of why I think he dropped her off in the alt_verse for no apparent reason in the first place: he'd moved on.).

Anyway, I can't wait to read the next part! You have me very intrigued!

P.S. Oh, and I love the idea of his semi-regeneration. Now I keep trying to imagine him with darker hair and green eyes (which must be a really pretty combination -- not that DT isn't already pretty anyway...).

Reply

persiflage_1 November 10 2008, 14:18:26 UTC
Handy + alt!Martha = PURE WIN!

*grins*

This was really good and I can't wait to read more. Rose is admittedly a bit OTT in this, but then, isn't she always? I always felt so bad for Handy in JE when, just after kissing him, she ran after the dematerializing TARDIS. I knew it could only really go downhill from there. I mean, yes, Handy looks like the Doctor, but he isn't -- he's some weird amalgam of the Doctor, Donna, and his own self. I hate stories that forget about that aspect of himself and I am glad that you didn't shy away from the inherent inner struggle that poor guy must have. I can only imagine that would make his relationships really difficult -- especially if Rose is expecting some sort of carbon-copy of the Doctor to grow old with (which honestly, that also assumes he hasn't had any emotional growth since she left, but with the exception of the weird reset-ness of the finales, he has changed -- which is honestly part of why I think he dropped her off in the alt_verse for no apparent reason in the first place: he'd moved on.).

Yes, she really was OTT, and thoughtless and selfish in the way she behaved during the S4 finale. Whinging on at Ten when she got him shot by a Dalek and he almost regenerated, and then bitching about having to look after Handy (not that I think Ten did the right thing there. In fact, I doubt anyone could convince me he did!)

Anyway, I can't wait to read the next part! You have me very intrigued!

Thanks!

P.S. Oh, and I love the idea of his semi-regeneration. Now I keep trying to imagine him with darker hair and green eyes (which must be a really pretty combination -- not that DT isn't already pretty anyway...).

I'd love to see David with green contacts and darker hair... Yum!

Reply

jadekirk November 10 2008, 16:12:34 UTC
I'd love to see David with green contacts and darker hair... Yum!

Or green eyes and red hair... :D

Reply


Leave a comment

Up