mostly Lie to Me

Jan 23, 2010 11:52

I have blazed through all the Lie to Me that there is so far, and I find myself a little disappointed. I really loved season 1. Season 2...much less so. And it's entirely because Gillian went from being an equal partner in the plot, with agency and an interesting role, to being a fairly one-note subordinate. If this continues through the rest of ( Read more... )

lie to me, castle

Leave a comment

pellucid January 24 2010, 20:08:07 UTC
I don't mind "edgier" at all, and I did like the last few eps of season 1 a lot. But I do mind if "edgy" translates into shoving everyone but Cal into the background and making Gillian, in particular, far less awesome than she had been.

And thank you for that intended episode order. I don't know that it changes things dramatically, but yes, there are a few moments that definitely make more sense if seen in that order. And I'd like to say that putting "Grievous Bodily Harm" and "Fold Equity" back to back, and then "Lack of Candor" afterwards shows progression: that we get Cal at his most reckless, and then an acknowledgment of what it looks like when someone else's life is threatening to spin out of control, etc. But then "Secret Santa" sort of works against the idea that Cal learned his lesson after GBH and FE.

I want the Cal from "Do No Harm" where he's constantly aware of the toll the kidnapping case takes on Gillian. He seems clueless about what he's doing to her this season.

YES! I want the scene after "Grievous Bodily Harm" when Cal realizes that Gillian missed the suicidal girl and has been dealing with that while he's been off with Terry. Or an acknowledgment of how hard the case in "Black Friday" must have been for Gillian--easily as difficult as "Do No Harm," yet it's as though everyone has somehow forgotten that a case about an adopted child might bring up issues for her.

So yes, here's hoping the back half of the season does a better job with some of this.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up