How finicky is too finicky?

Mar 03, 2016 15:39

So I'm going over the scanned text of The Dubious Hills to catch errors and to confirm its correspondence with the originally published version. Early on, something reminds Arry of "one of Beldi's paintings." I had forgotten that Beldi ever painted anything, and was considering this in the light of the short stories (all striving to be novels, ( Read more... )

itallcomesroundagain, the dubious hills, publishing, editing

Leave a comment

sartorias March 3 2016, 22:47:25 UTC
#3, add 'anymore' to the sentence?

(I have to admit that I am a continuity freak once I trip over something, though these are almost all image-related.)

Reply

pameladean March 3 2016, 23:18:49 UTC
Yes, that is actually an elegant possible solution; I will have to think on it.

I think being a continuity freak is a very useful quality in a writer.

P.

Reply

tiger_spot March 3 2016, 23:39:32 UTC
That was my immediate thought.

Reply

pameladean March 4 2016, 02:19:23 UTC
Now I wonder why it wasn't mine!

P.

Reply

mizkit March 4 2016, 08:21:12 UTC
Because writers are people who will never use one word when thirty will do. :)

Reply

alecaustin March 4 2016, 00:25:25 UTC
This seems like the most elegant fix that actually addresses things.

Reply

pameladean March 4 2016, 02:19:49 UTC
Yes, it does; I will probably adopt it unless I am smitten with inspiration in the middle of the night.

P.

Reply

rachelmanija March 5 2016, 07:59:32 UTC
No, wait, I actually like this suggestion better than mine.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up