R3 - Challenge Eight - VOTING
Well, we have to say goodbye to two very talented icon makers, _euphory & pushing_pin for not getting thier entries in. Thank you both for participating. - Obviously, I'm still catching up. And now, we just have 8 participants left. I thought there were a few more, but I guess not. So, there are two more challenges left. The results of this one will determine our 'semi-finalists' and the results of challenge nine will announce our top two or three finalists for the final challenge. Nervous now? Vote!
Skipping: none
PLEASE MAKE SURE YOU READ ALL THE RULES CAREFULLY
-You are voting for the LESSER quality icons. Not the icons you like least, not the style you may not care for, but the OVERALL QUALITY OF THE ICON IN GENERAL. Look carefully at the cropping, coloring, sharpening, photo quality and text. Please do your best & try not to be biased..meaning just because you don't like a certain style, that doesn't make it a bad icon. Be open-minded, but be critical.
-Comment to this post with THREE (3) icons. With these THREE votes, you MUST provide a reason to why you have voted for them. If you do not follow the rules and provide an explanation as to why you've voted the icon off, your vote WILL NOT be counted. If I find that your reasoning is biased toward an individual icon maker or an individual style you may not like, your vote will NOT be counted. Again, you're voting for THREE icons, which THREE will be booted out this time, and you must provide a brief explanation as to why you voted for them. Comments are screened. Anonymous votes will not be counted.
-After you vote for the THREE lesser quality icons, you'll be voting for your ONE FAVORITE ICON. You don't have to give a reason, although you can if you like. JUST CHOOSE ONE FAVORITE.
Here's an example of how to vote:
100: The texture is overpowering and the image is too sharp.
092: The image is very blurry and the color doesn't compliment the screencap.
122: The image is oversharpened and too smooth.
FAVORITE (explanation is optional)
207: I loved the color management and crop.
PLEASE LOOK AT ALL THE ICONS BEFORE YOU DECIDE WHICH HAS LESSER QUALITY
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
Don't forget : You are voting for 3 (THREE) lesser (with explanations), 1 (ONE) better icon
Good Luck!
Important Links
Rules [link]
Participants [ link]
Skips [ link]
Skipping: none
PLEASE MAKE SURE YOU READ ALL THE RULES CAREFULLY
-You are voting for the LESSER quality icons. Not the icons you like least, not the style you may not care for, but the OVERALL QUALITY OF THE ICON IN GENERAL. Look carefully at the cropping, coloring, sharpening, photo quality and text. Please do your best & try not to be biased..meaning just because you don't like a certain style, that doesn't make it a bad icon. Be open-minded, but be critical.
-Comment to this post with THREE (3) icons. With these THREE votes, you MUST provide a reason to why you have voted for them. If you do not follow the rules and provide an explanation as to why you've voted the icon off, your vote WILL NOT be counted. If I find that your reasoning is biased toward an individual icon maker or an individual style you may not like, your vote will NOT be counted. Again, you're voting for THREE icons, which THREE will be booted out this time, and you must provide a brief explanation as to why you voted for them. Comments are screened. Anonymous votes will not be counted.
-After you vote for the THREE lesser quality icons, you'll be voting for your ONE FAVORITE ICON. You don't have to give a reason, although you can if you like. JUST CHOOSE ONE FAVORITE.
Here's an example of how to vote:
100: The texture is overpowering and the image is too sharp.
092: The image is very blurry and the color doesn't compliment the screencap.
122: The image is oversharpened and too smooth.
FAVORITE (explanation is optional)
207: I loved the color management and crop.
PLEASE LOOK AT ALL THE ICONS BEFORE YOU DECIDE WHICH HAS LESSER QUALITY
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
Don't forget : You are voting for 3 (THREE) lesser (with explanations), 1 (ONE) better icon
Good Luck!
Important Links
Rules [link]
Participants [ link]
Skips [ link]