This is by no means a completed list (should be pretty clear that). I thought it would be good to start compiling a list of fics that I really enjoyed and would love to read again (if I haven't already). I've already read a motherload of fics and have only now started to compile this list, so I'm hoping those fics that I really enjoyed and never saved will crop up again and I can add them here.
Comment with your favourites too! I can always do with more reading. :)
Wincest
Title:
The Sunless Land by
lyra_wingPairing: Dean/Sam
Wordcount: 10,000+
Summary: High-school AU, in which Sam and Dean don't know each other. But, of course, not everything is what it seems. [NC-17]
Note: The tension was wonderful within this fic, at no point was I bored or thought the story was over-drawn. Everything was balanced, and I just enjoyed the story immensely.
Title:
Your Heart Held Out Like A Tin Cup To Catch The Rain by
philomelPairing: Dean/Sam
Wordcount: 1, 813
Summary: If there's one dream left, Dean is going to hold on and keep it there, as long as he can. [PG-13]
Note: This fic was just so exquisitely written. The prose was just mind-blowingly beautiful.
J2
Title:
Getting Dressed in the Dark by
sazzlettePairing: J2
Wordcount: 60,000
Summary: Jared and Jensen-mortal enemies throughout high school-never thought that they would eventually end up as stepbrothers when Jensen’s divorced father asks Jared’s widowed mother out to dinner. Becoming a family takes more than sharing a house, but when the boys discover that they’re not as different from each other as they might have thought, being related gets a whole lot more interesting. High school and college bring their share of troubles with girls and schoolwork. But as Jared and Jensen’s perceptions of each other change and grow into something more, will they be prepared for the fallout? [R]
Note: Now this is certainly a fic I've read more than once. Wonderfully engaging, the tension between the two brothers and the slow progression from enemies to friends to something more was wonderfully done.