Guatemalan mom loses son to US couple

Jul 19, 2012 09:36

Tug-of-Love: Immigrant Mom Loses Effort to Regain Son Given to US Parents


Read more... )

race / racism, adoption, guatemala, undocumented immigration, missouri, immigration, children

Leave a comment

perrie July 19 2012, 15:15:01 UTC
It's awful, but if the mother has been in jail for five years, her son has been fostered out and the American family took him on for a closed adoption, I'm not surprised her case got turned down. Biological parents are not always the best people to raise a child. Bear in mind I don't know how American social services works, but I will agree that her not being provided with a translator is incredibly callous.

Reply

69love_songs July 19 2012, 15:24:38 UTC
"Biological parents are not always the best people to raise a child"

True in some cases, but it sounds like this decision has been made on the fact she was in the country illegally. To me, that's not a strong enough argument for taking somebody's child away.

Reply

chaya July 19 2012, 16:59:02 UTC
Or the decision was made not because she was undocumented but because her undocumented status led to her being jailed and thus unable to parent? (Not that this is completely cut-and-dry obvs)

Reply

69love_songs July 19 2012, 17:07:07 UTC
I find it pretty awful that somebody with a young child (11 months is still a baby!) can be jailed for being undocumented tbh. I find it very hard to believe anyone would work illegally in a chicken processing factory, risking arrest, deportation and jail time just for the lolz. This is fucked up.

Reply

chaya July 19 2012, 17:09:46 UTC
No argument here. Even if you believe in deportation etc of undocumented workers, nobody can argue that the way the kids are handled is anywhere near humane.

Reply

sapitacherry July 19 2012, 15:27:35 UTC
She was released in 2009 and has been allowed to stay in the US as her case was going through the system.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up