The Name Change Dilemma

May 15, 2011 21:21

The Name Change Dilemma

by Sue Shellenbarger
Friday, May 13, 2011


Read more... )

marriage, women

Leave a comment

(The comment has been removed)

windy_lea May 16 2011, 04:05:56 UTC
I don't think I will, either. Even if name-changing weren't inconvenient and confusing, the simple fact is that I consider my name to be part of my identity. I've lived 24 years with this name, and I should just scrub it off and tack on someone else's identity?

I respect that others no doubt view it differently, and think the choice is legit either way, but I'm partial to my can-you-tell-me-how-to-spell-that? last name.

Reply

romp May 16 2011, 08:01:03 UTC
I've lived 24 years with this name, and I should just scrub it off and tack on someone else's identity?

This always seemed hella presumptuous to me!

Reply

windy_lea May 16 2011, 16:33:35 UTC
That's why it pisses me off so much when some men make a big fucking fuss about women who don't want to take their husband's name. It takes real fucking entitlement nerve for a man to make it all about his wounded pride feelings when he's asking someone to rebrand themselves in a way he will likely never be expected to. If she doesn't care, cool, but family names mean things to some people. You'd think the guy who's busy trying to spread his would get that.

Reply

sobota May 16 2011, 10:10:58 UTC
my surname is a name my father chose to be less conspicuous when coming to america (he came in during the iranian revolution, and his original surname was nice and muslim). so i've dealt with a fake surname all my life, and i'd like something that was truly mine.

Reply

windy_lea May 16 2011, 16:46:09 UTC
I could see how that could feel like... a pseudonym, I guess? Or at least like something that just doesn't quite fit. If you don't mind my asking, are you considering reverting to the original surname, or are you hoping to find the right fit along the way?

My mother raised me, so I'd probably feel very differently about the prospect of changing my name if I had my father's name. Different circumstances definitely make for different feelings regarding one's current surname.

Reply

sobota May 16 2011, 17:00:07 UTC
i live in france so i would be hesitant to change my surname to a muslim one, and my father and i aren't terribly close so i probably wouldn't. but i have no issues changing my surname to my future husband's/wife's, just so i can gain something closer to an identity that is actually mine.

Reply

windy_lea May 16 2011, 17:09:51 UTC
Ah, okay, that certainly makes sense. :)

Reply

maladaptive May 16 2011, 15:00:33 UTC
Yep. When I was little I came up with elaborate schemes for name-changing equality, because it seemed really dumb that I would have to change my name to a boy's name because... because... because "stop asking it's tradition!"

Tradition has never been a good excuse to me, not even when I was 5.

Then I turned out to be a lesbian so it's all moot anyway, but BOY did the subject make me angry as a little kid. My last name is just as good as a boy's name!

Reply

windy_lea May 16 2011, 16:47:00 UTC
My last name is just as good as a boy's name!

Hear, hear!

Reply

lady_deirdre May 17 2011, 12:28:36 UTC
I agree completely with your comment.

My last name is complicated and unusual, but it's mine and it's me. Giving that up would mean letting go of a part of my family and my history that I don't want to lose. Also, having a rare last name means that preserving it is an issue. This name could end with me and my brother, so I'm hanging onto it tyvm.

Reply

windy_lea May 19 2011, 01:15:09 UTC
You raise another good point wrt name preservation. My family name is reasonably rare, and since we tend to have more girls than guys, it'd be all too easy for our name to disappear in a single generation if we all took a husband's name.

Reply

vldtheimpaler May 17 2011, 13:32:54 UTC
Same. I don't see the point in this day and age. If I ever have kids, I'd want them to have my name, too, and not my husbands.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up