The FISA Act: Listening to "compromise"

Jul 16, 2008 17:13

Published: July 8, 2008

By Morton H. Halperin


Read more... )

fisa

Leave a comment

sore July 16 2008, 22:10:21 UTC
It is honestly so strange for me moving to a country where everything seems so... different compared to where I'm from.

Reply

ladypolitik July 16 2008, 22:11:39 UTC
Yeah? You're moving to the States? (Dun-dun-dunnnn.)

Reply

potatoboat July 16 2008, 22:23:13 UTC
(dramatic reverb)

Reply

ladypolitik July 16 2008, 22:29:07 UTC
sore July 16 2008, 22:23:21 UTC
Hah, yeah, I think so. I already have American Citizenship ... but all the news I read and the things that go on down here ... blah. It's certainly a deterrent. Along with the general outlook on Politics, Medicare, and taking care of their own damn people.

As a general POV, it sure says a lot about a society when they feel they can't even trust their own citizens. Misrepresentation ftw. This isn't about keeping Americans 'safe' - it's about exploiting their 'God-given' rights already outlined in the Constitution. I call bullshit.

Reply

ladypolitik July 17 2008, 02:08:34 UTC
Hahaha. It should be an interesting experience. :)

Yes, the very basic idea that these surveillance mechanisms were put in place after 9/11, supposedly as some "anti-terrorism safeguard", is utter bullshit of the highest kind.

Still, what are we supposed to make of the author of the article, a victim of government surveillance back in the 70s, but insists there's more to the bill than what everyone supposedly realizes?

I'd rather the whole concept of domestic surveillance be done away with, period. Of course, that's not happening any time soon. Which leaves the U.S. public with, what--a "weaker" FISA bill than whatever the Bush admin would've preferred to have seen approved by the Senate? And if so, how "weak" are we talking? And what mechanisms would have been used/pursued had the bill failed?

Personally, that's where I get stuck, yet it seems few people--including those who condemned the bill--are able to provide a nuanced, comprehensive breakdown of the legal logistics around those sort of questions.

/verbose

Reply

flowerings July 17 2008, 02:05:45 UTC
Where are you from? Why are you moving here now?

Reply

sore July 17 2008, 04:18:10 UTC
Canada - American boyfriend. :( He's getting Canadian citizenship too since (generally; don't jump on me) Canada's Social Advances > America

Reply


Leave a comment

Up