Who do you blame more for Juliet's death?

[drbat]

Poll Who do you blame more for Juliet's death?Who do you blame more for Juliet's death? Sawyer blames Jack, but I think Kate's more responsible because if it wasn't for her Sawyer and Juliet would have just left on that submarine.

EDIT: The question is who out of the two do you think is more responsible (since in the ep Sawyer blames Jack but not Kate). It doesn't mean that that person is 100

Comments

[just_smiling]

Kate... because the creators are so obsessed with that character that all of the other female characters have suffered because of it.

[indierocket]

this!

[iamtheliquorr]

MTE!

I find it also hilariously ironic that the character they clearly expend the most time and energy on is also the most poorly developed and useless

[oneloveunited]

Sun?

Penny?

Eloise?

[just_smiling]

Story and quality wise. Non of the female characters have had as much screen time and focus as Kate has. She's been dwindled down to "which man will she choose?" stories that take up way too much storylines and screen time. Hell, even the ABC special only mentioned as much as that.

And because the writers have such a hard on for Kate/Evie the other females have been a blip on the LOST storyline radar... and never get any focus. Hell, they vanished Claire and gave her story to Kate to try and make her interesting.

Also, Penny & Eloise are recurring characters... not main characters.

[oneloveunited]

She still has to find Claire and who knows whats in store for her in the alt timeline.

I don't think the writers ruining any of Sun's potentially interesting storylines has anything to do with Kate/Evi...

Like I said, Eloise was very interesting on her own, nothing to do with Kate. I'm guessing she'll be back this season, too so...

[just_smiling]

Kate shouldn't have to "find" Claire. Claire should be able to have her own story. Same with Sun...and Juliet. But Juliet was given the leftover piece in the "Who will Kate choose" square.

I don't think the writers ruining any of Sun's potentially interesting storylines has anything to do with Kate/Evi...

But what story is that? The only female that they spend much time giving storylines to is Kate. That's just how it is. Throughout the entire series Kate had to be involved in everything while doing nothing... while the other females were just there. Most of the time being too "pregnant" or "old" or "girly" to do anything within the bigger storyline. Only occasionally did any of the females get to do something... and then when that happened it almost always resulted in their characters death.

Like I said, Eloise was very interesting on her own, nothing to do with Kate. I'm guessing she'll be back this season, too so...But she's had about two episodes, and is nothing more then a background character thus far... we don't know

[oneloveunited]

Well, they could've switched Sun around with Jin, had her go on the raft, get caught by the tailies, help Des rescue Naomi, "die" on the freighter while he is rescued, help Rousseau, skip through time then live in the 70s...but instead they make her pregnant and give him all of the activities.

Basically, I think the issue is with the writers being better at writing male characters, something that's very common in TV and movies today.

[just_smiling]

I fully agree the writers are to blame. Also, their obsession with Kate doesn't help.