Peer Critique: #19
If you entered an icon in the previous OIcontest (posted here) you may reply to this post with a comment that contains your entered icon(s). You may only submit icons to be critiqued that were entered in the previous contest. We will be checking.
Anyone is free to respond to the comments with constructive criticism. What that means is that every response must have (1) a compliment and (2) something that can be improved about the icon.
OK: I think the color is fantastic, but I would have used a different font or It's a very strong icon overall, but I think the compression is off: maybe try optimizing it?
NOT OK: It's okay but overall it sucks or It's perfect in every way and the only thing wrong is that it didn't win first place!
When commenting, please remember that many different people, with many different skill levels, entered this contest. Please choose your words carefully - the worst-looking icons are most likely made by the people newest to icontests. Share your wisdom!
Icon-makers, please take these comments with a grain of salt. The most important thing is that you are happy with your icons. And without further ado...
Let the commenting commence!
(jiatra thought of this and actually wrote the majority of this post. We love her, worship her, and if we could, would build small statues of her everywhere.)
Anyone is free to respond to the comments with constructive criticism. What that means is that every response must have (1) a compliment and (2) something that can be improved about the icon.
OK: I think the color is fantastic, but I would have used a different font or It's a very strong icon overall, but I think the compression is off: maybe try optimizing it?
NOT OK: It's okay but overall it sucks or It's perfect in every way and the only thing wrong is that it didn't win first place!
When commenting, please remember that many different people, with many different skill levels, entered this contest. Please choose your words carefully - the worst-looking icons are most likely made by the people newest to icontests. Share your wisdom!
Icon-makers, please take these comments with a grain of salt. The most important thing is that you are happy with your icons. And without further ado...
Let the commenting commence!
(jiatra thought of this and actually wrote the majority of this post. We love her, worship her, and if we could, would build small statues of her everywhere.)