EDIT: My mathing was off and the score has been updated!
Let me preface by saying that I will not be including the Descendants’ canon in this post.
This is something that has been ruminating in my brain since October 2020. It started coming up in dreams and it felt like there was no escape. I knew I had to get to the bottom of this idea. Is this comparison needed? Probably not. Does this theory need to be pushed out into the world? Absolutely it does.
Hypothesis: Dr. Facilier became Oogie Boogie after being pulled to the Other Side.
To test this hypothesis, I will present 6 arguments and rate them against a weighted 4-point rubric. 1 - Unsatisfactory 2 - Marginal 3 - Good 4 - Excellent
In case you are unfamiliar with these characters, here is a quick refresher: [Le Dossier]
Dr. Facilier
Oogie Boogie
Alias: The Shadow Man Alias: The Shadow in the Moon
Species: Human Species: Sack of bugs
Origin: New Orleans, LA Origin: Halloween Town, Holiday Forest
Iconic Song: Friends on the Other Side Iconic Song: Oogie Boogie’s Song
[Let us begin] 1. Characters in the Disney Universe Both Dr. Facilier and Oogie Boogie are part of the Disney, ergo they could be tied to the same universe. Here are photos of them from Oogie Boogie’s Halloween Bash at Disneyland’s California Adventure.
Rubric score: 3 - Good
2. Timelines match up The Princess and the Frog takes place in 1926. The decade for A Nightmare before Christmas is unknown, but it has to be after the 1950s because we see that there are color TVs. Using cues from the setting, I’m placing the events in the late 1980s.
Rubric score: 4 - Excellent
3. Common Imagery Some say that when one passes into the Afterlife, they bring along some qualities they held when they were alive. I have reason to believe this is true for Dr. Facilier and Oogie Boogie. A. Cards Dr. Facilier used tarot cards to tell Prince Naveen and Lawrence’s past, present, and future. Oogie Boogie likes to use playing cards to decorate his lair.
B. The color green Like myself, they appear to favor a light green color.
C. Circles They have a thing for circular designs.
D. Skulls They also have a thing for skulls.
Rubric score: 4 - Excellent
4. Penchant for gambling One of the first things we hear Dr. Facilier say to Prince Naveen is that “he’s not a gambling man.” However, in his next sentence he proceeds to offer a gamble of wager. So what is the truth sir?
Friends on the Other Side was written by Randy Newman, while Danny Elfman wrote Oogie Boogie’s Song. Could it be that they were due to be divinely connected from the start?
Rubric score: 4 - Excellent
Final Rubric score:
[Are you ready to find out?]20/30 (66.7%) 20/24 (83.3%) In conclusion, I have found that there is an 67% chance 83% chance Dr. Facilier did indeed turn into Oogie Boogie when he as pulled to the Other side.