Term 01: Battle 01 Results
Here are the results for the first Battle! Sorry for the slight delay, but I hope it hasn't spoilt your enjoyment!
Elimination:
by Mitsuru Bandou
People's Choice:
by Sano
Mod's Choice:
By Aya.
Mod's Comments:
It's cute, funny with a lovely array of bright colours. More than anything it has impressive cropping without losing any detail of the image used. The background textures are gentle and let the imagery speak for itself, and they've used a good combination of fonts that work well together.
01: -5 +0 = -5
02: -1 +3 = +2
03: -0 +4 = +4
04: -2 +3 = +1
05: -4 +3 = -1
06: -4 +2 = -2
07: -4 +1 = -3
08: -0 +3 = +3
09: -4 +0 = -4
10: -1 +0 = -1
Reminder of the icons...?
As you can see, it was a real close call, and it came down to the last vote to break the tie. Thank you all for taking part, and commiserations to Mitsuru Bandou. Hopefully you'll re-enter in the Comeback Challenge.
Banners:
I really wanted banners to celebrate the winners (and losers), but as it was pointed out to me (before we started) that would reveal the identity of the winners (and losers), so banners wont be made until the end of the Term.
If you want to receive your critiques then please respond with a comment. All replies will be screened and therefore anonymous. If you don't receive e-mail notifications then let me know in your comment, along with your e-mail address.
Battle 2 is about to commence!
Elimination:
by Mitsuru Bandou
People's Choice:
by Sano
Mod's Choice:
By Aya.
Mod's Comments:
It's cute, funny with a lovely array of bright colours. More than anything it has impressive cropping without losing any detail of the image used. The background textures are gentle and let the imagery speak for itself, and they've used a good combination of fonts that work well together.
01: -5 +0 = -5
02: -1 +3 = +2
03: -0 +4 = +4
04: -2 +3 = +1
05: -4 +3 = -1
06: -4 +2 = -2
07: -4 +1 = -3
08: -0 +3 = +3
09: -4 +0 = -4
10: -1 +0 = -1
Reminder of the icons...?
As you can see, it was a real close call, and it came down to the last vote to break the tie. Thank you all for taking part, and commiserations to Mitsuru Bandou. Hopefully you'll re-enter in the Comeback Challenge.
Banners:
I really wanted banners to celebrate the winners (and losers), but as it was pointed out to me (before we started) that would reveal the identity of the winners (and losers), so banners wont be made until the end of the Term.
If you want to receive your critiques then please respond with a comment. All replies will be screened and therefore anonymous. If you don't receive e-mail notifications then let me know in your comment, along with your e-mail address.
Battle 2 is about to commence!