3.06: "The Body in Question"

Feb 12, 2012 13:46

Summary: A frozen body discovered in the local river could cause a world-wide historical revolution: was Napoleon Bonaparte at Waterloo or was he ice fishing near Cicely and fathering a tribe of French-speaking Native Americans?

Moosechick's episode guide page.

season three

Leave a comment

icepixie February 12 2012, 19:53:38 UTC
Hee, I love Joel's hypothermia-induced dream. In the same way he didn't expect a two-hundred-year-old Frenchman to write "Elba not bad," he didn't expect Elijah to wear a suit. Nor, for that matter, to show up at all, because while he does seem to have some kind of belief or faith, he doesn't expect his religious figures to actually speak back to him.

"The soul is the sacred payload of us all," and the body doesn't matter. Maurice and Holling should probably never talk about metaphysics. It would end badly.

Holling: [Great-Uncle Whoever's] death is still celebrated in some parts of France.
Shelly: You mean like Lincoln's birthday?
Holling: I mean like the death of Satan.

1.) Why is Lincoln's birthday the first thing Shelly, a Canadian, thinks of in this situation? 2.) Hee.

Ruth-Anne: Ed, I think you can do anything you put your mind to.
Ed: Why?
Ruth-Anne: Why not?

MY HEART GROWS THREE SIZES EVERY TIME I WATCH THIS. (It's going to come busting out of my chest any day now!)

Also, yay Ed for not going back to pay-to-read consultants! I like how his C-plot fits in with the debate in the church, especially, because in the same way different readings of facts will produce different interpretations of the "truth," his script is about his subjective experience of life, which, though the consultant says it "sounds familiar," of necessity must be unique in some manner. (As Grandma Woody said two episodes ago, if he writes about what he actually sees in front of him, his story will be different from anyone else's.)

(Alternately, Ed just isn't a very good writer. But I refuse to believe that!)

Mwahaha, sure, Marilyn knows absolutely nothing about where the body went, nope, nothing at all...

"I am NOT making a habit of this." And yet she says she'll come back in an hour, and in the last episode she was playing nursemaid as well, and in the next two episodes she looks in on him when Elaine comes to visit and when he gets broken up about a dead bird, so really, in this case I think actions speak louder than words...

OMG THE ENDING. These people knew how to write an ending. (Or how to quote for an ending. WHATEVER, I STILL GET CHILLS DOWN MY BACK.)

Reply

rowdycamels February 15 2012, 03:16:01 UTC
1.) Why is Lincoln's birthday the first thing Shelly, a Canadian, thinks of in this situation?

Add to the list of things Shelly is bad at: being from Canada.

(Alternately, Ed just isn't a very good writer. But I refuse to believe that!)

It sounds like he... is finding his feet. The boy's got potential!

Reply

icepixie February 15 2012, 05:39:12 UTC
Add to the list of things Shelly is bad at: being from Canada.

Awwww. Perhaps she should take lessons from Fraser. (Can you IMAGINE them interacting?)

Reply

rowdycamels February 18 2012, 23:51:19 UTC
She'd love him! No one else takes her so seriously and politely! Poor Fraser, on the other hand...

Reply

icepixie February 19 2012, 19:18:42 UTC
Awwwww, she would totally talk him into a hair-braiding party and spend hours telling him about hockey in Saskatchewan! (Actually, he might enjoy the hockey part.) And then he would make up an emergency somewhere far, far away.

(Heh, I'm also imagining Maggie's reaction to him. I think it would take the form of flirting so aggressively she scared him right back to Chicago.)

Reply

rowdycamels February 27 2012, 04:04:49 UTC
"I'm terribly sorry, ma'am, but my wolf informs me we've been recalled to the Yukon."

I think it would take the form of flirting so aggressively she scared him right back to Chicago.

And taking every opportunity to remind Joel that Joel isn't polite, well-mannered, and gentlemanly!

Reply

icepixie February 27 2012, 05:01:07 UTC
And taking every opportunity to remind Joel that Joel isn't polite, well-mannered, and gentlemanly!

Yes, yes, she would! (Although the strange thing is, he's totally polite and well-mannered when they get out of Cicely! It's like the Alaskan air turns him into a cranky, self-centered jerk!)

Reply

rowdycamels February 29 2012, 02:15:26 UTC
Although the strange thing is, he's totally polite and well-mannered when they get out of Cicely!

Whaaaaaaat?

Reply

icepixie March 1 2012, 01:20:32 UTC
When he and Maggie go to visit her mother and grandmother in Michigan (I'm sure I showed you this one, as it has a very young James Marsters as an Episcopalian reverend who hates listening to people's personal problems), he's super polite--lots of pleases and thank yous, says complimentary things to various family members, offers to hold bags and coats... He doesn't even complain to anyone except Maggie, and even then it's toned way down!

Reply

rowdycamels March 1 2012, 02:36:58 UTC
Whaaaaaaaaaaaaaaat??

Reply


Leave a comment

Up