“Antwerp is not ready to elect an Orthodox Jew”

Apr 22, 2018 15:56

An extraordinary story over the last few days from Belgium, which I have not seen covered in the international press at all ( Read more... )

world: belgium

Leave a comment

Comments 13

steepholm April 22 2018, 14:12:26 UTC
In similar vein, there's this recent story from France.

Reply


redfiona99 April 22 2018, 19:51:31 UTC
The BBC reported on something similar with an Algerian lady who was denied citizenship because she refused to shake hands with the (male) official at the ceremony.

Reply


anonymous April 27 2018, 23:41:49 UTC
What you conveniently left out is that mr Berger was convicted a few years ago for stealing money from a dying man. He also stated other "harmless" religious beliefs such as "mixed education is child abuse" and his opposition to gay rights. He has every right to hold these prehistoric beliefs, but it's perfectly understandable that the party decided to drop him.

Reply


andrewducker May 7 2018, 09:05:11 UTC
"conditional on fitting in to the dominant traditions of society and not looking or behaving differently"

Not being willing to shake hands with half of your constituents because of something they have no control over isn't as simple as "the dominant traditions of society". Religion isn't a good reason to overlook people's beliefs or behaviours.

Reply

mme_n_b May 7 2018, 19:04:32 UTC
What's so important about shaking hands? As long as he's willing to treat women as men in all respects that do not involve physically touching them (I doubt he would, but let's entertain the possibility), why is it an issue? Would you feel the same if a Muslim woman was not able to be elected because she would not shake hands with men?

Reply

andrewducker May 7 2018, 19:46:35 UTC
I'd feel exactly the same as if they were willing to shake hands with one colour skin, but not another.

Which is: I find this abhorrent and do not want this person representing me in any way.

Reply

mme_n_b May 7 2018, 20:25:59 UTC
From which I gather that you do not see a difference between "they are lesser than me" and "they are forbidden to me"?

Reply


Leave a comment

Up