Behind the cut is the short list of winners for the Season Three Nummy Awards.
- Overall
- Best Episode [44.4%]
- Best Guest Actor [35.6%]
- 1. Lou Diamond Phillips as Agent Ian Edgerton (Spree, Two Daughters, and Pandora’s Box)
- Best Guest Actress [54.5%]
- 4. Kathy Najimy as Dr. Mildred Finch (Various Episodes)
- Most Evil FBI Nemesis [42.9%]
- 3. Prophet Abner Stone, who was the leader of the polygamist cult the Apostolic Saints (Nine Wives)
- Least Bright FBI Nemesis [38.1%]
- 3. Daria Sampson, who allowed Kentwell Construction to bury hazardous materials on school property in exchange for money for her school board campaign (Waste Not)
- Wardrobe
- Best Charlie Wardrobe [22.7%]
- 10. Unbuttoned burgundy shirt and black jeans (Provenance)
- Best Don Wardrobe [22.7%]
- 1. Olive green T-shirt, jeans, sunglasses, and gun (Two Daughters)
- Best Alan Wardrobe [18.6%]
- 4. Brown suede jacket and white button down shirt (Pandora’s Box)
- 5. Gray suit and spotted tie (Provenance)
- Best David Wardrobe [30.2%]
- 3. Leather jacket and jeans (Contenders)
- Best Larry Wardrobe [25.6%]
- 2. Orange spacesuit (The Art of Reckoning)
- Best Amita Wardrobe [22%]
- 8. Purple jacket and top with blue jeans (Killer Chat)
- Best Megan Wardrobe [32.6%]
- 2. The unseen red cowgirl pjs (Hardball)
- Best Colby Wardrobe [26.2%]
- 7. Gray T-shirt and white zipper jacket (The Janus List)
- Miscellaneous
- Best Charlie Hair Scene [50%]
- 6. Turning on the MRI (The Janus List)
- Best Jeans of Justice Scene [33.3%]
- 5. Standing on the rooftop (The Janus List)
- Best Shot of Don with Gun Drawn [56.1%]
- 1. Shooting Crystal Hoyle before she has a chance to ram into the blockade (Two Daughters)
- Best Shot of David with Gun Drawn [35.7%]
- 3. Hiding under the seats in Disney Hall and handing Colby a gun (One Hour)
- Best Shot of Megan with Gun Drawn [29.3%]
- 2. Protecting Naomi Vaughn in the firefight (The Janus List)
- Best Shot of Colby with Gun Drawn [42.5%]
- 1. Preventing Crystal Hoyle from escaping the blockade (Two Daughters)
- Best Romantic Pairing [51.1%]
- 1. Larry and Megan
- Best Technique to Hide Diane Farr’s Pregnancy [39.5%]
- 2. A grocery sack (Nine Wives)
- Quotes and Dialogue
- Best Charlie Quote [33.3%]
- 8. “I love… I love working with my brother.” (Money for Nothing)
- Best Don Quote [33.3%]
- 7. “He's this curly headed black hole that can suck the air out of the universe.” (Money for Nothing)
- Best Alan Quote [51.1%]
- 1. “Larry, I’m going to give you the same advice I given to all of the geniuses I know. Don’t be an idiot.” (Spree)
- Best David Quote [31.8%]
- 1. “Do you get the feeling everybody's forgotten about us?” (Spree)
- Best Larry Quote [26.7%]
- 2. “No, I don't I want to remain a blithering idiot. Yes, of course I want your honesty.” (The Mole)
- 10. “Greetings gravity bound homo sapiens, I am orbiting your lovely blue planet until the middle of the earth year 2007. You may leave a message here or simply call out to the heavens. I will be listening.” (The Art of Reckoning)
- Best Amita Quote [33.3%]
- 2. “Just think she could be your boss and your step mom.” (Waste Not)
- Best Megan Quote [20.5%]
- 1. “I will never get tired of being compared to the M57 nebula.” (Spree)
- Best Colby Quote [35.6%]
- 2. “Just nod your head and wait for the punch line.” (Two Daughters)
- Best Guest Star Quote [20%]
- 6. “So I almost get shot and you guys respond by doing a lot of math?” (Oswald Kittner in Hardball)
- Best Sarcastic Remark [22.7%]
- 4. “Next time you’re running. I'm driving.” (Colby in One Hour)
- 8. “Knowledge plus a guess. Where I come from that’s a hunch.” (Ian Edgerton in Spree)
- Most Painfully Awkward Line (TM theoriginalspy) [43.2%]
- 1. “I'll make sure it doesn't rain. You know my brother can do things with math. He's a genius.” (Don in Blackout)
- Best Dialogue Quip [31.8%]
- 9. Charlie: Are you thinking what I’m thinking?
Colby: No. (Brutus)
- Best Dialogue [31.1%]
- 8. Dr. Bradford: You grew up in the shadow of Albert Einstein, playing baseball just not good enough to make the bigs, and you finally found something that you’re good at. You’re terrified that’ll be taken away from you, too.
Don: Yeah. Well, I mean, you know, this isn’t exactly making me feel a hell of a lot better.
Dr. Bradford: If you want to feel better, take a pill. You wanna get it right, face the truth. You’re not worried about your team falling apart because you’re not there, you’re afraid that they won’t. That Don Eppes doesn’t matter.
Don: Well, you said it, there’s a lot of guns and badges out there, you know. I mean, one of us falls, there’s someone right there to take our place.
Dr. Bradford: That’s pretty much the human condition, Don. It’s what you do before you fall, that’s what counts. (One Hour)
- Technical
- Best Written Episode [45.5%]
- 4. One Hour by Ken Sanzel
- 5. The Janus List by Robert Port and Ken Sanzel
- Best Storyline [51.1%]
- 1. The team solves a kidnapping case while Don is at his therapy session (One Hour)
- Best Camera Angle [18.6%]
- 4. The overhead shot at Little Tokyo when Oswald skateboards through the Japanese girls (Hardball)
- Best Supporting Role by a Prop [18.2%]
- 5. The green fluted bowl (Various Episodes)
- 6. Milk as a champagne substitute as the group toasts Larry’s trip to the International Space Station (Killer Chat)
- Best Set [63.6%]
- 1. The Eppes home (Various Episodes)
- Best Filming Location [60.5%]
- 3. Disney Concert Hall (One Hour)
- Best Song [28.6%]
- 2. Hallelujah by k.d. lang (Provenance)
- Favorite Writer [69%]
- 1. Ken Sanzel (Spree, Two Daughters, Brutus, One Hour, and The Janus List)
- Math
- Best Math Concept [43.9%]
- 3. The fact that Shuffle Mode on your iPod isn't really random because it never repeats (Traffic)
- Best Math Vision [35.7%]
- 7. Don figuring out that that Taylor Ashby planted bombs in a picture of the G major scale (The Janus List)
- Best Scene Where Charlie Writes an Equation [62.8%]
- 3. Writing on the hospital window next to Taylor Ashby (The Janus List)
- Best Teaching Scene [45.2%]
- 3. Larry and Charlie demonstrating the impenetrable armor of physics (Spree)
- Scenes
- Best Charlie Scene [34.1%]
- 2. Vouching for Larry’s character to NASA (Killer Chat)
- Best Don Scene [35.6%]
- 5. Discussing his team and trust issues with Dr. Bradford (One Hour)
- Best Alan Scene [32.6%]
- 1. Playing chess with Larry and discussing how to tell Charlie Alan is thinking about moving out of the house (Spree)
- Best David Scene [36.4%]
- 3. Being cool under fire (literally!) in the lemon grove (The Art of Reckoning)
- Best Larry Scene [36.4%]
- 6. Berating Charlie for calmly doing math after Megan is kidnapped (Two Daughters)
- Best Amita Scene [25%]
- 2. Telling Millie that she doesn’t appreciate being disrespected in front of a colleague (Waste Not)
- Best Megan Scene [29.5%]
- 4. Convincing Che Lobo to allow the FBI to help rescue his son from the kidnappers (One Hour)
- Best Colby Scene [29.5%]
- 4. Rescuing Jo Santiago from the kidnapper Nacio Duque on the stage at Disney Hall (One Hour)
- Best Guest Star Scene [31.8%]
- 4. Pony meeting his daughter Lucy (The Art of Reckoning)
- Best Eppes Family Scene [32.6%]
- 4. Don and Charlie at a session with Dr. Bradford talking about the camping trip when Don was thirteen and Charlie was eight (Money for Nothing)
- Best Comic Scene [31.8%]
- 3. Don and Charlie comparing notes about Megan and Larry and laughing over the fact Megan finds Larry “beautiful” (Traffic)
- Best Action Scene [27.9%]
- 4. The chase through the lemon orchard (The Art of Reckoning)
- Best Takedown Scene [46.5%]
- 3. Charlie taking out the Black Rain International assassin with the active MRI machine (The Janus List)
- Best Romantic or Flirty Scene [20.5%]
- 5. Charlie and Amita’s kiss in the garage (Waste Not)
- Best Awkward Scene [34.9%]
- 2. Alan coming home early and interrupting Charlie and Amita’s poker date (Contenders)
- Best Non Eppes Scene [36.4%]
- 4. Colby running all across town only to find David under the seats at Disney Hall (One Hour)