Leave a comment

Comments 6

flenceburgsbest July 21 2009, 05:31:25 UTC
As this is a personal, um, friend of mine, I will refrain from voting.

However, I will clarify that the personality and background checks out. The dream is also downright gorgeous, in my opinion. Very symbolic.

Reply


shurimon July 21 2009, 15:15:20 UTC
Also abstaining due to personal bias. *g* Jesse's one of my oldest friends and one of the first people I RPed with, so I don't feel I can be impartial.

Reply


10th_division July 21 2009, 16:18:56 UTC
Not only am I familiar with the canon, but it's one of my favorites.

The background DOES check out, and I know the difficulty of writing one in which the story involves conflicting political powers and such. It doesn't have things detail for detail, but in the same way that Pixie was able to summarize Harry Potter's seven books in a fairly compact but encompassing manner, that's how this background strikes me. There were some embellishing descriptions that made it less concise and a little harder to get through or understand, and I don't know how others who aren't as familiar will handle it.

The ability descriptions are good, too.

I vote Yay.

Reply


redrobinhood July 21 2009, 19:26:30 UTC
I enjoyed the personality section and the background was consistent. Since Ten and Ami are vouching for canon, I vote yes.

Reply


rustyarmor July 21 2009, 23:44:33 UTC
Canon was verified, and I feel it's consistent and shows thought, so I'll vote yes.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up