Something I Haven't Done in Years

Jul 16, 2005 23:51

Nothing smutty...sorry to disappoint you ( Read more... )

Leave a comment

daisyfair July 17 2005, 22:43:42 UTC
you read it all? i'm on like page 35 but i keep falling asleep. so i have guesses on stuff just b/c i've had a few years to guess but i have no clue on the plot yet.

did you like?
don't tell me anything else though!

Reply

nonoluna July 17 2005, 23:04:32 UTC
I did like...it's not my favourite. That spot is still solidly possessed by Goblet of Fire. There's much learned in this book and it totally sets up book 7.

Reply

daisyfair July 17 2005, 23:27:49 UTC
that's what i've heard! i have theories about dumbledore and aunt petunia but now i'm only 60 pages in so that's not much

why goblet?

Reply

nonoluna July 18 2005, 02:45:06 UTC
I was wrong about Petunia...oh, well.

Goblet had a fantastic story with the Triwizard tournament. I love his development and how he coped with things. Then the ending with Voldemort rising again is just unbelievably gripping. It gelled for me, I guess.

Which has been your favourite so far?

Reply

daisyfair July 18 2005, 04:27:00 UTC
what's gelled?
i'm not sure about my favorite. i remember 4 being the one where i was like wow this is so for adults now. which is 4? i think that might be my favorite. 5.. it was long and a bit confusing and i also just wasn't sad about sirius ya know? i mean i hadn't connected.

shoot you were wrong about petunia?! shoot!

Reply

nonoluna July 18 2005, 10:50:29 UTC
By gelled I mean that everything worked in the right way for me. Most people liked Prisoner best.

My theories on Petunia may not have been yours. I was wrong about other things too...:-(

Reply


Leave a comment

Up