Comments | noah_who: "It looks like I'm gonna be eating second-rate sushi for a lot longer than I thought."

rhiannonhero in noah_who

"It looks like I'm gonna be eating second-rate sushi for a lot longer than I thought."

Mar 14, 2011 10:28

Alice had to hit the hay before she could post today's rewatch, so I'm posting on her behalf.

Oh happy day! Today's episode sees the demise of the toxic Nuke relationship forever and ever! Hooray!

We begin with Reid and Katie talking about the new neuro wing. Reid goes to the fridge, gets Katie a bottle of water, and unscrews the cap for her. What ( Read more... )

bob has a man crush on reid, poor bb luke, reid please cuddle luke, katie is banana to reid's peanut butter, luke puts on his big boy pants, luke/reid rewatch, luke gets his drama on, luke's hair makes baby jesus cry, luke = love, being noah's boyf is v depressing :(, comment fic, noah is scared of luke's peen, messing with luke's big gay head, luke has bitch face

Leave a comment

Back to all threads

qjilla28 March 14 2011, 15:21:05 UTC

Welcome to Oakdale, Dr. Oliver!!! And with every episode, our love for you grows....

The broken flower pot! I cannot for the life of me, comprehend how ANYONE could be a fan of Luke and Noah. Noah actually comes out and SAYS that he knows he is being selfish (he just leaves out the But I really don't give a shit part). There is just nothing to root for with this couple. I mean, Luke is crying you douche bag. Although Luke may have just been crying over Noah's sweater....

Enter Mr. Judd. And now it starts to all get soooo good....
(Reply to this)

bigboobedcanuck March 14 2011, 17:57:28 UTC

I cannot for the life of me, comprehend how ANYONE could be a fan of Luke and Noah. Noah actually comes out and SAYS that he knows he is being selfish (he just leaves out the But I really don't give a shit part).

Right? It boggles the mind. I mean on one hand, if Noah was just like, I'm being selfish, but I need to do it -- and then it was over with Luke and he didn't expect Luke to be waiting like a dog for Noah to snap his fingers and want him again -- that would be fine. The bigger thing underneath it all is that Noah knows damn well that he doesn't want to be with Luke forever. As he says, things change. And that's okay! But Noah is such a motherfucking asshole later when Luke and Reid get together, insisting that Reid "stole his boyfriend."

Despite my obvious hatred of the ending of canon, at least Noah ends up alone in LA. That's something.

rhiannonhero March 14 2011, 18:35:20 UTC

Where he will wait tables until the end of time.

bigboobedcanuck March 14 2011, 18:37:10 UTC

Amen, sister. Amen.

cindergal March 14 2011, 19:06:15 UTC

Yeah, that was kind of a classic case of I don't want you until somebody else does, wasn't it? Too little, too late, Noah.

nancygrew March 15 2011, 01:28:52 UTC

But Noah is such a motherfucking asshole later when Luke and Reid get together, insisting that Reid "stole his boyfriend."

ITA! But the fact that Noah is such an ass makes it even funnier when he's so surprised that things have changed with Rooftop!Luke. If it wasn't for the whole train thing, the ending of the Reid/Luke/Noah triangle would have been sooooo satisfying for LURE and/or Luke fans. Noah is written as such a horrible, selfish, abusive and ANGRY jerk that the fact that Luke ends up in a great relationship with someone else is fitting and perfect. It's like Noah was actually written as something for Luke to overcome instead of a viable love interest.

smittle March 15 2011, 07:39:04 UTC

So true! Finally Luke gets the wonderful relationship he deserves with Reid and Noah can only explain Luke not running back to him by demonizing Reid for stealing Luke.

Remember a few episodes back when you commented that you had only 499 reasons to hate Noah? I'll bet it's back up to 500 now because Noah showed up.

Back to all threads