Leave a comment

hermioneann February 6 2011, 03:08:42 UTC
I think most teachers would probably agree with you about the testing being crap, though I heartily disagree with the homeschool part (school isn't just book learning). Sadly, it's not teachers making those calls.

Interestingly enough, the school ratings in Indiana at least used to be based on test *improvement* rather than just scores. I remember there being a big hullabalo when the school I went to had its ranking dropped. But, if you looked at the scores, they had an amazing pass rate. They just hadn't improved over the last year; the system didn't take into account you can only improve so far.

Reply

nightshade1972 February 6 2011, 04:34:17 UTC
That's right. School is *not* just book learning. But there have been so many instances of one or two unruly students in the public school system ruining a field trip for the rest of the class, many districts have decided to forgo field trips altogether. Every homeschooling parent I've ever talked to has told me that they make it a special point to take their child(ren) to museums, zoos, concerts, etc as part of their learning experience. Another big reason I'm in favor of homeschooling is that if your child excels in a given subject, as a parent you can make the choice to spend a little extra time immersing your child in that subject. Public school districts are basically hogtied by curriculum requirements, so they simply don't have any "extra" time to devote to ensuring that the slower children don't get left behind, and the brighter children don't get bored ( ... )

Reply

garthelive February 7 2011, 13:59:10 UTC
Amazing that you could write so much on a topic without bringing up your mother.

Reply

nightshade1972 February 7 2011, 18:53:01 UTC
That's because anyone who's been following my LJ from the beginning already knows that she taught music in the public school system for over twenty years, and spent another four years after retiring from the public system teaching music in a private Lutheran school.

Reply

garthelive February 11 2011, 20:53:39 UTC
I've read your whole journal and this is the longest entry that is not full of stuff about your mother.

Reply

garthelive February 11 2011, 20:54:09 UTC
With the possible exception of one or two about how you know more than your doctors.

Reply

shermes January 23 2012, 06:33:17 UTC
What makes sense to me is a mixture of public school and homeschooling. E.g. a really bright middle-schooler skips eighth grade, learns twice as much that year because he's/she's not being slowed down by a public school curriculum, and then enters high school better prepared for an honors/AP track. I think that could really put a student ahead, and maybe give him/her an early opportunity to learn how to stick to a self-designed study schedule (super helpful in college).

Reply

nightshade1972 January 23 2012, 06:46:18 UTC
Most of the homeschooling parents I've talked to over the years stopped homeschooling around the time their child was going to start HS. The older your child gets, the harder it is to teach them a given subject, unless the subject is something the parent did/does for a living. So when their kid gets to be about 14, the child takes the test which lets the school district know what grade level to put them in, then the parents can choose to put them in either public or private school.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up