HP7 Review [SPOiLERS]

[neoyi]

I remember entering the world of Harry Potter as a middler schooler in her 8th year, having needed to read the first book in our English class. Having been exposed to the boy wizard, I have since kept up with it throughout the years and have now been graced with the seventh and final chapter detailing the life of the boy who lived. Now after

Comments

[cirihttthecat]

dude I allways love you reviews ^_^

and how about remus? , like he was one of my faves male characters since the third book , but here he was acting like an ass , besides his relationship whit tonks for me was always like bleh

[neoyi]

I wanted to smack him when he refused to side with Tonks and her unborn child. That said, his death with Tonks I just felt was SO wasted and unneeded.

[tavalya_ra]

I'm glad Harry did give him the verbal smackdown, but he felt unauthentic as a fount of this wisdom. Tonks needed more development all around- because of the lack of it, I had little opinion about the relationship.

[neoyi]

*nods* I never could get into Lupin/Tonks because I also felt it came out of the blue, I just felt angry with Lupin that this rather patient teacher from Book Three turned into a hardcore jerk for that brief moment. It seemed so un-Lupin of him to do so.

[tavalya_ra]

I gave up on the books applying too much logic in the characterization after book five. She pulled the same trick with Sirius. He went from responsible to reckless, too. I'm glad at least Dumbledore and Snape were consistent- when they acted in a way that didn't seem like how you would expect, you discovered why and it fit after all.