Results - Challenge 3 - Round 5

[tout_moi]

Hello guys! Challenge 3 Round 5 voting is closed. Thanks for your votes!

i_we_you will conduct next round!


Eliminated:


dance_the_dance

So sorry! Thanks for participation! Hope to see you next challenge!

People's choice:


llean
Banner

Mod's choice:


tory_guvera
Amazing colours, nice crop!
Banner

Results:
1. +4
2. -1+1=0
3. -2+1=-1
4. -3

Reasons:
negative:
# 2
- coloring is too yellow (but I don't really blame the maker, the original imaged difficult coloring) also crop would be better if it showed all of her lips
# 3
- this icon is without smth special (against the background of other pics)
- too dark
# 4
- not enough contrast and in general the icon is kinda boring
- too simple, needs more contrast
- simple b/w icon, and icon need more contrast
positive:
# 1
- great composition)
- original, with good contrast
- interesting size of image, pretty crop
- icon is clear and very original
# 2
- bright, beautiful coloring, good crop
# 3
- good crop and contrast of black and white