Results - Challenge 3 - Round 3

[tout_moi]

Hello guys! Challenge 3 Round 3 voting is closed. Results under cut!

i_we_you will conduct next round!


Eliminated:


i_we_you

So sorry! Thanks for participation!

People's choice:


dance_the_dance
Banner

Congrats!!!

Mod's choice:


lihana
Nice composition, good texture choice!)
Banner

Results:
1. +4
2. -2
3. +1
4. +1
5. -5
6. +1

Reasons:
negative:
# 2
- icon looks oversharpened, crop isn't good
- bad quality, hair colour is a bit blue like background
# 5
- Too much contrast, the image looks a little too dark. Also, the text and its placement look wrong.
- too darck coloring, and text loocks not well
- text doesn't go well with the image
- too much contrast, the icon looks oversharpened and the text doesn't fit (the style and the text itself)
- Coloring is slightly too contrasted and the text doesn't fit at all, it's too much/big.

positive:
# 1
- I really like the simplicity of the icon. Good cropping and use of tiny text.
- good crop and use of tiny-text
- textures are lovely
- good quality of the picture, and the textures are used good. the B\W makes it really elegant
# 3
- nice crop and texture use
# 4
- beautiful background/ great cropping, good use of tiny text. Everything in this icon fits really well together, although skin is a little too red but this is not a big deal here
# 6
- nice composition, use of text is good