Results - Challenge 3 - Round 1
Hello everyone! Challenge 3 Round 1 voting is closed. Sorry for delay!
Actually we don't have enough votes, but I think waiting for your votes more is useless.
i_we_you will conduct next round!
Eliminated:
welleg_fic
So sorry! Thanks for participation! Hope to see you next session!
People's choice:
alice_trip
Banner
Congrats!!!
Mod's choice:
i_we_you
I really love the cropping, it so nice! Colouring is amazing.
Banner
Results:
1. -1+1=0
2. -1+2=+1
3. +1
4. -1
5. -5
6. -1+1=0
7. -1+2=+1
8. -2+3=+1
9. -1
10. -1+2=+1
11. +2
Reasons:
negative:
# 1
- Oversaturated. Also, that light texture doesn't go well with the image.
# 2
- If I didn't already know who it was, I would have no idea.
# 4
- coloring is too pale and boring crop
# 5
- image looks grainy, pale colouring
- the crop is ok,but the colors look so washed out
- the coloring looks pale and dirty
- The colors are really pale
- colors look dirty
# 6
- too much textures + text isn't good
# 7
- colouring is original, but pale. Oversharpened
# 8
- The location of the text is distracting.
- too dark
# 9
- strange choice to make Nelly in B/W and the background in color, looks as if the maker wanted to bring up the wall, and not the person
# 10
- two parts of icon don't really go together, also it's not exactly tiny text, it's readable text flipped mirror-like and upside down ;)
positive:
# 1
- gorgeous coloring! (maybe the light is a bit too harsh though)
# 2
- neat crop, the hair fit so well and you can tell it's Nelly
- Stunning colors! It's just amazing how you managed those colors from a very yellowish picture.
# 3
- nice b\w, crop
# 6
- The cropping and coloring are both awesome.
# 7
- good crop and the coloring is outstanding
- The coloring is excellent.
# 8
- nice texture use and text placement
- Text placement's just clever. Beautiful crop, too.
- interesting crop, and the text fits in, its bright color contrast nicely with the background
# 10
- pretty colors and crop
- pretty colors and crop, textures are lovely too
# 11
- nice colouring, crop, texture use
- nice colouring
Actually we don't have enough votes, but I think waiting for your votes more is useless.
i_we_you will conduct next round!
Eliminated:
welleg_fic
So sorry! Thanks for participation! Hope to see you next session!
People's choice:
alice_trip
Banner
Congrats!!!
Mod's choice:
i_we_you
I really love the cropping, it so nice! Colouring is amazing.
Banner
Results:
1. -1+1=0
2. -1+2=+1
3. +1
4. -1
5. -5
6. -1+1=0
7. -1+2=+1
8. -2+3=+1
9. -1
10. -1+2=+1
11. +2
Reasons:
negative:
# 1
- Oversaturated. Also, that light texture doesn't go well with the image.
# 2
- If I didn't already know who it was, I would have no idea.
# 4
- coloring is too pale and boring crop
# 5
- image looks grainy, pale colouring
- the crop is ok,but the colors look so washed out
- the coloring looks pale and dirty
- The colors are really pale
- colors look dirty
# 6
- too much textures + text isn't good
# 7
- colouring is original, but pale. Oversharpened
# 8
- The location of the text is distracting.
- too dark
# 9
- strange choice to make Nelly in B/W and the background in color, looks as if the maker wanted to bring up the wall, and not the person
# 10
- two parts of icon don't really go together, also it's not exactly tiny text, it's readable text flipped mirror-like and upside down ;)
positive:
# 1
- gorgeous coloring! (maybe the light is a bit too harsh though)
# 2
- neat crop, the hair fit so well and you can tell it's Nelly
- Stunning colors! It's just amazing how you managed those colors from a very yellowish picture.
# 3
- nice b\w, crop
# 6
- The cropping and coloring are both awesome.
# 7
- good crop and the coloring is outstanding
- The coloring is excellent.
# 8
- nice texture use and text placement
- Text placement's just clever. Beautiful crop, too.
- interesting crop, and the text fits in, its bright color contrast nicely with the background
# 10
- pretty colors and crop
- pretty colors and crop, textures are lovely too
# 11
- nice colouring, crop, texture use
- nice colouring