Comments | nastynate4687: The Dark Knight

nastynate4687

The Dark Knight

Jul 20, 2008 21:21

OK I just got done watching the Dark Knight. Shit that was good. Non-stop action and suspense. And it was so fuckin dark. But I'm just left with so many questions ( Read more... )

Leave a comment

Back to all threads

anonymous July 21 2008, 15:45:49 UTC

I think Depp could replace Ledger as the Joker.

XIYU HU

nastynate4687 July 22 2008, 13:41:24 UTC

Good idea Huxi. That would be awesome. I'd really like to see Depp do a really crazy AND evil person. In pirates he was kinda crazy and eccentric but he was a good guy. And in Sweeny Todd he was kinda evil. I'd like to see him mash those two characters together, and get really extreme with it. It would be awesome.

blacklily013 July 25 2008, 20:38:40 UTC

Depp couldn't play the Joker I think. He won't ever be able to play him like Ledger does. Cause as I was watching the movie, I never once thought, "that's Heath Ledger." He was totally and completely the Joker. I don't think Depp could do it. I mean he's a brilliant actor, but I honestly think he would suck as the Joker.

nastynate4687 July 26 2008, 05:24:33 UTC

OK I also didn't think "that's Heath Ledger" when he was playing the Joker. It was partly because he had the makeup on that made his face less recognizable. But it was mainly his acting. He was so crazy, and so much better than any other role I've seen him in. So why can't the same happen to Depp? His face is more recognizable but the makeup could change some or most of that. I think it mainly comes down to the acting. If Depp can pull off the crazy evil diabolical anarchist then I think he could pull off the Joker very well, despite the fact that everyone would be like "hmmm that Joker looks kinda like Johnny Depp". It's the acting that brings you in, and if the acting is good enough, it will keep you in regardless of what the actual person looks like ( ... )

blacklily013 August 6 2008, 14:58:29 UTC

Oh I don't doubt Depp's acting abilities at all. He could pull off a fucking amazing Joker. I just don't think he could continue the Joker created by Ledger.

nastynate4687 August 6 2008, 18:09:10 UTC

I agree with that. I think only Ledger would be able to pull off HIS Joker, maybe, who knows. But that doesn't mean other people can't do their own Joker and have it be just as successful.

O and I've heard rumors that people are trying to cast Depp as the Riddler, and Philip Seymour Hoffman as the penguin. If that happens, the next Batman movie will be awesome, cuz those two guys are some of my favorite actors.

Back to all threads