630 Clicks later.....
Someone at BuddyTV is brilliant! They’re asking Supernatural fans to wallow in our obsession like hedonistic little piggies. They want to name the 10 best episodes of all time and they are willing to give all us fans a say in the matter. All you have to do is register (it’s fast and painless) and then you can have a say.
They have each of the seasons listed separately and you basically have to vote for one episode versus another until you’ve worked your way through the whole season. (252 votes for s1&2 and like 116 for s3) The best part (IMO) is that at the end of each season you get a list of your personal rankings. There’s also an overall ranking list that complies the votes from everyone.
For me the best part wasn’t seeing what my favorite episodes were. Any true fan can probably rattle off their top 3 from each season without blinking. No, the best part for me was getting to see the middle of the pack rankings. That and being able to compare the results with my friends were the best parts.
So here’s how mine came out. (best to worst by season)
S1
Devil’s Trap
Pilot
Salvation
Skin
Home
Shadow
Provenance
Nightmare
Dead Man’s Blood
Faith
Something Wicked
Bloody Mary
Hell House
Asylum
Dead in the Water
Phantom Traveler
Scarecrow
Route 666
Hookman
The Benders
Wendigo
S2
What Is And What Should Never Be
All Hell Breaks Loose 1&2 (they had them grouped together)
Born Under A Bad Sign
Children Should Play With Dead Things
In My Time Of Dying
Coratoan
Hunted
Heart
Nightshifters
Bloodlust
Crossroad Blues
Tall Tales
Houses Of The Holy
Simon Said
Folsom Prison Blues
No Exit
The Usual Suspects
Everybody Loves A Clown
Hollywood Babylon
Playthings
S3
No Rest For The Wicked
Mystery Spot
Dream A Little Dream Of Me
A Supernatural Christmas
Bad Day At Black Rock
Jus In Bello
Sin City
Red Shy At Morning
Malleus Maleficarum
Long Distance Caller
Bedtime Stories
The Magnificent Seven
The Kids Are All Right
Fresh Blood
Time Is On My Side
Here's the link to BuddyTV http://www.buddytv.com/articles/supernatural/vote-for-your-favorite-superna-22248.aspx