(no subject)
All right.
I am locking this post to Sha Gojyo, Obi-Wan Kenobi, Ash Ketchum, and Cho Hakkai.
Mr. Kenobi, I originally merely had some questions for you about your voting habits, but now there is information which I believe you need to see, as well. Sha Gojyo and Ash Ketchum are in the lock as I consider them to be cleared by clues. Cho Hakkai is in the lock because he has convinced me that he is a sheep - largely through the fact that unless proven otherwise by genuine clues, I believe the two wolves are Roy Mustang and Lady, and Cho-san has been suspicious of Mustang since day 1. Tobias is not included in the lock because I do not know him at all, and he may still be the third wolf, rather than Lady.
First of all, Mr. Kenobi, though I am convinced of your status as sheep at this point, may I ask if you have held off on voting in the suspicion polls as well as the ousting polls? If so, is this for moral or religious reasons, or simply because you did not feel like voting?
As for my remark above about genuine clues...
I believe that Mustang's clue is false.
1) It was delayed - yes, he may have been asleep, which would provide the reason why he missed the voting also, but isn't that rather convenient? I find it fascinating that he wouldn't feel the need to be awake for the voting; he must be confident in the abilities of his fellow sheep.
2) It calls into doubt a previously-solved clue when it would appear that we got it correctly - Sano-san distinctly appears to have been a wolf.
3) He carries on with the alpha-numeric translation, which presents more possible options than are permitted by the clue - the translation of his own invention.
EDIT: His explanation of A, K, L, O, S, S, W not having the O and W count seems like it could work - however, I still find his clue to be more than likely false; there are several doubts about each possible interpretation of the alpha-numeric translation which simply aren't there with Ying's list order translation - and as Ying was a sheep, and Ash seems to be a sheep by virtually any translation of the clue, I believe that Ying's was correct.
Dare I ask if any of you recieved a genuine clue? If you have, it would make this much simpler.
Please, discuss.
I am locking this post to Sha Gojyo, Obi-Wan Kenobi, Ash Ketchum, and Cho Hakkai.
Mr. Kenobi, I originally merely had some questions for you about your voting habits, but now there is information which I believe you need to see, as well. Sha Gojyo and Ash Ketchum are in the lock as I consider them to be cleared by clues. Cho Hakkai is in the lock because he has convinced me that he is a sheep - largely through the fact that unless proven otherwise by genuine clues, I believe the two wolves are Roy Mustang and Lady, and Cho-san has been suspicious of Mustang since day 1. Tobias is not included in the lock because I do not know him at all, and he may still be the third wolf, rather than Lady.
First of all, Mr. Kenobi, though I am convinced of your status as sheep at this point, may I ask if you have held off on voting in the suspicion polls as well as the ousting polls? If so, is this for moral or religious reasons, or simply because you did not feel like voting?
As for my remark above about genuine clues...
I believe that Mustang's clue is false.
1) It was delayed - yes, he may have been asleep, which would provide the reason why he missed the voting also, but isn't that rather convenient? I find it fascinating that he wouldn't feel the need to be awake for the voting; he must be confident in the abilities of his fellow sheep.
2) It calls into doubt a previously-solved clue when it would appear that we got it correctly - Sano-san distinctly appears to have been a wolf.
3) He carries on with the alpha-numeric translation, which presents more possible options than are permitted by the clue - the translation of his own invention.
EDIT: His explanation of A, K, L, O, S, S, W not having the O and W count seems like it could work - however, I still find his clue to be more than likely false; there are several doubts about each possible interpretation of the alpha-numeric translation which simply aren't there with Ying's list order translation - and as Ying was a sheep, and Ash seems to be a sheep by virtually any translation of the clue, I believe that Ying's was correct.
Dare I ask if any of you recieved a genuine clue? If you have, it would make this much simpler.
Please, discuss.