Must we be witnesses to insanity when help is refused? Or are we required to act?

May 10, 2008 14:04

Citing the fact that the Myanmar regime is, in active and stubborn negligence, allowing its citizens to starve, contract diseases and fall into lawlessness, Time magazine has come up with a radical proposal: ( It is time to invade Burma )

war, burma, disasters, military

Leave a comment

gigiss May 19 2008, 20:28:37 UTC
You overlook the fact that it is all about perceptions. You perceive the U.S. as The Benevolent Nation (which we are, make no mistake about it). Others, however, have as little confidence in our motives as we would in the motives of North Korea or Iran.

But ultimately, despite the sensitivity of these perceptions, we still have to decide what is the Right Thing To Do. I happen to agree with the rage that you feel for governments who are oppressing their own citizens. I just wish that there was a way to find a solution that did not involve our citizens dressed in camo and flak jackets and worrying about IEDs.

And ultimately, I am sobered by the realization that I am not going to be the one who will be in the line of fire should we get to that point. My boys will be the ones shouldering that burden, and while it would make me proud to know that they are defending the rights of humanity, I am not quite sure that I am ready to expose them to the possibility of that kind of sacrifice yet. Selfish of me? Maybe, but that is how I feel right now.

Reply

myrgthful May 20 2008, 06:31:29 UTC
I see what you mean. I worry about either of my daughters wanting to enlist in the military, at some point in the future, too. But I would be a hypocrite to try to resist the idea.

And all of our soldiers are volunteers. They know - or should know - what they are getting themselves into.

I also feel that just being a missionary in a foreign country these days presents its own challenges and dangers. Sister Barbara Barrington Jones' daughter had to return early from a dangerous situation in Central America, around '92, when I lived in your stake.

Worse, I worry about what living in "the last days" portends for them. In Israel, surrounded by enemies, the men AND women both serve in the military, and take home skills like using a gas mask, firing a rifle, and emergency field-medicine. Stuff like that. Will it be the same for us when "the Constitution hangs by a thread" and some of the worst parts of prophecy begin to occur?

It's not that I am crazy about the idea of going to war, or drawing the anger of terrorists. (In truth, I believe they would hate us even if we weren't in Iraq, simply because we are "infidels" to them, and we are powerful... and I'd rather they deploy IEDs in a foreign territory, than against us in American Suburbia) It is that I believe that it is our role to be prepared for the utmost worst. And to be willing to face whatever adversities which come, like our Pioneer ancestors before us.

Returning from my tangent... maybe we ought to hope that people will be willing and able to act for their own good, and that we can try to just drop supplies in to them. It just seems that most people are not able to or willing to defend themselves.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up