(no subject)
Your Muse: God
Muse wanted: CHUCK. Any other SPN or Dogma peeps (minus Metatron).
Community: SWS
Fandom: Supernatural, Dogma
Canon: Intersecting canons
Book, Movie, Game, Other: TV Show/Movie
PB: Show / Movie casts preferably
Contact via: Here is lovely!
So I caved and made this account, which is all good fun, but then I came across the problem with Chuck. We're presented with Chuck as God, so I had a hard time figuring out how to work Dogma God into SPN canon. This is what I came up with:
God can do anything. She's God. The Alanis body is a vessel she's made for herself, therefor not a real vessel, therefor holding her real voice. This is why she can't talk to humans in that body. Chuck on the other hand is like John Doe Jersey, a human vessel that she's using in order to hide. In Dogma she did it to get away and play skeeball, and in SPN she did it for other secret reasons. This begs the question: John Doe Jersey never spoke. Chuck does, a lot. BUT In that scene where Chuck is writing, dressed in white and seeming far more Godlike than he ever was, he isn't speaking. We hear inner monologue, but no speaking.
SO WHAT I'M LOOKING FOR is mouthpiece Chuck. A Chuck who IS his own person, a prophet in his own right, who also happens to be a vessel of God. It would explain the change in character in that scene, the fact that Chuck still calls sex lines and wants to date Becky, the fact that his relationship with Becky just stops without warning or explanation, the fact that Zachariah and Raphael didn't recognize him as God and the fact that he was so surprised by what was supposed to happen to Sam and Dean.
Long story short, I PUT FORTH THAT IN SPN, God is hiding inside of Chuck and using him as a mouthpiece.
Muse wanted: CHUCK. Any other SPN or Dogma peeps (minus Metatron).
Community: SWS
Fandom: Supernatural, Dogma
Canon: Intersecting canons
Book, Movie, Game, Other: TV Show/Movie
PB: Show / Movie casts preferably
Contact via: Here is lovely!
So I caved and made this account, which is all good fun, but then I came across the problem with Chuck. We're presented with Chuck as God, so I had a hard time figuring out how to work Dogma God into SPN canon. This is what I came up with:
God can do anything. She's God. The Alanis body is a vessel she's made for herself, therefor not a real vessel, therefor holding her real voice. This is why she can't talk to humans in that body. Chuck on the other hand is like John Doe Jersey, a human vessel that she's using in order to hide. In Dogma she did it to get away and play skeeball, and in SPN she did it for other secret reasons. This begs the question: John Doe Jersey never spoke. Chuck does, a lot. BUT In that scene where Chuck is writing, dressed in white and seeming far more Godlike than he ever was, he isn't speaking. We hear inner monologue, but no speaking.
SO WHAT I'M LOOKING FOR is mouthpiece Chuck. A Chuck who IS his own person, a prophet in his own right, who also happens to be a vessel of God. It would explain the change in character in that scene, the fact that Chuck still calls sex lines and wants to date Becky, the fact that his relationship with Becky just stops without warning or explanation, the fact that Zachariah and Raphael didn't recognize him as God and the fact that he was so surprised by what was supposed to happen to Sam and Dean.
Long story short, I PUT FORTH THAT IN SPN, God is hiding inside of Chuck and using him as a mouthpiece.