2009 Reading List - V for Vendetta
Book Fourteen
V for Vendetta by Alan Moore and David Lloyd
(Sorry for the delay - I've been caught up with Japanese study, which slows down my regular reading pace quite a lot....)
There are people who think that comic books are just for kids. They see Superman and Batman and Spider-Man, with their bright costumes and their rather simplistic moral codes and think, "Well, that's all well and good for children, but as a thinking adult, I need something more.” Some of these folks are lit-snobs, who view any kind of book with pictures as immature. Perhaps they were told that they need to grow up, and have distanced themselves with comics as they have done with their own childhoods. Or perhaps they simply don't know better....
The point is that while there certainly is a lot of childish dross in comics, there's also a lot of gold. In the right hands, a great story can be told in any medium, be it print, painting, film, stage, or yes - even comics. In this case, the right hands are those of Alan Moore and David Lloyd.
Moore is considered one of the giants of modern comic books, having penned many a dark and strange tale, ignoring the accepted norms of comic book storytelling in order to tell the weird and off-kilter stories that he wants to tell. In the famous Watchmen, Moore told us about the flaws and imperfections inherent in the heroic ideal. In V for Vendetta, he looks at the flaws and imperfections in our societies and ourselves.
The book is set in an alternate London, a place that Could Have Been. In this world, the worst of our modern nightmares has happened - a nuclear war that ravaged many parts of the world. Europe, Africa, these places were, as the characters put it, “gone.” England survived the turmoil by the skin of its teeth, pulling itself up from chaos and disorder thorough the strength of the new government party, Norsefire.
This government is unapologetically fascist. In the turmoil following the war, they saw the only solution to England's survival in absolute obedience. And so they built a new England - an England of strict rules and laws, with ears and eyes everywhere. Minorities of all kinds were systematically wiped out from the country. Blacks, Muslims, homosexuals - anyone who didn't fit into the world view of the new leadership was eliminated, and in many cases just disappeared. The government espouses a doctrine of absolute control over its citizenry, seeing that as the only defense against the horrors that the world had just barely survived.
But, for all that, England prevailed. People were safe in their homes, as long as they followed the rules. They were entertained with radio and television, given plenty of amusements and a health dose of fear to keep them in line. The government of England seemed almighty, governed by their fascist ideology and a massive supercomputer, known simply as Fate. Nothing, they thought, could challenge their supremacy.
Until V arrived.
With no name, and no face besides the Guy Fawkes mask he wore, the terrorist known as V began to cut a swathe through the ruling elite. All that is known of him is that he had been a prisoner in one of the concentration camps set up by the government. In that place, terrible experiments were done on the human detritus of society - experiments with truly horrific results. Whether V's incredible mind and physical ability were because of those experiments or despite them, we will never know. All we do know si that he survived, and with a single-minded determination bordering on madness, he sought revenge.
With public demonstrations of terrorism and pyrotechnics, he took it upon himself to wrest control of the city from those who had locked it down. His goal is freedom for everyone, anarchy in its truest sense, and he will not be stopped.
As the title suggests, this is a vendetta on many levels. It is revenge for what was done to V in the prison camps where they took all the “undesirables,” and for what was done to England by its new rulers. V is a man with nothing to lose, and everything to gain - not just for himself, but for his country.
This is a book about freedom on many levels. It's about political freedom, which makes it especially relevant today, and it's no coincidence that the film emerged during the headiest days of the Bush administration. Following the attacks of September 11th, Americans were afraid, and the government - like the government of this book - was all too willing to harness that fear in exchange for control. People were told to watch what they say about the President, the government or the troops. Television pundits and spokespeople demanded that criticism be shut down, and that those who disagreed with what the country was doing were branded traitors.
Fortunately, we got through those frightened times, but even today, those who would stay in power use fear to keep people in line. Fear of death, fear of immigrants, fear of gays - fear of The Other - are the first weapons they use to command obedience from their citizenry.
And most people fall in line very easily. It's not surprising, really. Most people, when they're afraid, look to someone to take care of them, to protect them and to tell them what to do. It's a natural impulse, a natural need of human beings. But V exhorts us to move past that. He reminds us that, in a quote from the film, “People should not be afraid of their governments - governments should be afraid of their people.” While our government never reached the depths of the one in this book, it is something that all citizens of all countries should remember.
The book is also about personal freedom. We are all of us prisoners, really - prisoners of our societies and prisoners of ourselves. We are held down by our preconceptions , our doubts and our illusions; our own minds and our beliefs about what others expect of us are what keep us locked into a prison whose bars we cannot even see. V freed himself from his own literal and spiritual confinement to go from prisoner to a societal force, bursting free in an explosion of flame and destruction. He meets a young woman, Evey Hammond, and brings her into his world - partly to be his accomplice, but also to show her how to be free. Her freedom comes at a cost too, enduring the greatest nightmare of a citizen of a fascist society. But she survives, and finds her freedom in the rain and the dark.
The lesson that V teaches us, whether as individuals or societies, is twofold: we hold ourselves prisoner, and there is no more vicious or cruel jailer than ourselves. And that freedom is frightening - it is wild and uncontrolled, and never comes without a price. But that price is well worth paying.
To be honest, it took me a long time to finally enjoy this book. When it came out originally, I was big into super-hero books, and V struck me as just goofy. Why would someone wear such a dumb mask? I thought. And that hat? The cloak is okay, but.... Of course, I knew nothing of Guy Fawkes at the time, so perhaps my ignorance of British history held me back, but still, I was very impatient with it. Also, the art was much rougher and darker than I was used to. The usual four-color palette and clean inks of super-hero comics are not to be found in this book. Instead there are washes of pale purple and yellow and green, with heavy inks and faces full of sorrow and pain.
In other words, it was not what I expected from a comic, and so I gave it a wide berth. And that was probably for the best, since I think that having a better idea of politics and society makes the story that much more interesting. It's a complex and multi-leveled tale that deserves a thoughtful read, and asks a lot from its reader, and if you expect to get through it without doing some thinking of your own, then you'll be sorely disappointed.
That is, however, the mark of a great work - does it make you think? Does it come back to you later, when you're watching the news or reading the newspaper? When you see a story about the pervasiveness of security cameras and think, "I wish V were here," then Alan Moore and David Lloyd have truly done their jobs.
V isn't the hero we expect from comics. He isn't the hero we'd necessarily want, either. But a person like V is necessary sometimes - someone who values freedom above all else. Let us hope that we never need him.
-------------------------------------------
"Noise is relative to the silence preceding it. The more absolute the hush, the more shocking the thunderclap.
Our masters have not heard the people's voice for generations, Evey... and it is much, much louder than they care to remember."
- V, V for Vendetta
-------------------------------------------
V for Vendetta by Alan Moore and David Lloyd
(Sorry for the delay - I've been caught up with Japanese study, which slows down my regular reading pace quite a lot....)
There are people who think that comic books are just for kids. They see Superman and Batman and Spider-Man, with their bright costumes and their rather simplistic moral codes and think, "Well, that's all well and good for children, but as a thinking adult, I need something more.” Some of these folks are lit-snobs, who view any kind of book with pictures as immature. Perhaps they were told that they need to grow up, and have distanced themselves with comics as they have done with their own childhoods. Or perhaps they simply don't know better....
The point is that while there certainly is a lot of childish dross in comics, there's also a lot of gold. In the right hands, a great story can be told in any medium, be it print, painting, film, stage, or yes - even comics. In this case, the right hands are those of Alan Moore and David Lloyd.
Moore is considered one of the giants of modern comic books, having penned many a dark and strange tale, ignoring the accepted norms of comic book storytelling in order to tell the weird and off-kilter stories that he wants to tell. In the famous Watchmen, Moore told us about the flaws and imperfections inherent in the heroic ideal. In V for Vendetta, he looks at the flaws and imperfections in our societies and ourselves.
The book is set in an alternate London, a place that Could Have Been. In this world, the worst of our modern nightmares has happened - a nuclear war that ravaged many parts of the world. Europe, Africa, these places were, as the characters put it, “gone.” England survived the turmoil by the skin of its teeth, pulling itself up from chaos and disorder thorough the strength of the new government party, Norsefire.
This government is unapologetically fascist. In the turmoil following the war, they saw the only solution to England's survival in absolute obedience. And so they built a new England - an England of strict rules and laws, with ears and eyes everywhere. Minorities of all kinds were systematically wiped out from the country. Blacks, Muslims, homosexuals - anyone who didn't fit into the world view of the new leadership was eliminated, and in many cases just disappeared. The government espouses a doctrine of absolute control over its citizenry, seeing that as the only defense against the horrors that the world had just barely survived.
But, for all that, England prevailed. People were safe in their homes, as long as they followed the rules. They were entertained with radio and television, given plenty of amusements and a health dose of fear to keep them in line. The government of England seemed almighty, governed by their fascist ideology and a massive supercomputer, known simply as Fate. Nothing, they thought, could challenge their supremacy.
Until V arrived.
With no name, and no face besides the Guy Fawkes mask he wore, the terrorist known as V began to cut a swathe through the ruling elite. All that is known of him is that he had been a prisoner in one of the concentration camps set up by the government. In that place, terrible experiments were done on the human detritus of society - experiments with truly horrific results. Whether V's incredible mind and physical ability were because of those experiments or despite them, we will never know. All we do know si that he survived, and with a single-minded determination bordering on madness, he sought revenge.
With public demonstrations of terrorism and pyrotechnics, he took it upon himself to wrest control of the city from those who had locked it down. His goal is freedom for everyone, anarchy in its truest sense, and he will not be stopped.
As the title suggests, this is a vendetta on many levels. It is revenge for what was done to V in the prison camps where they took all the “undesirables,” and for what was done to England by its new rulers. V is a man with nothing to lose, and everything to gain - not just for himself, but for his country.
This is a book about freedom on many levels. It's about political freedom, which makes it especially relevant today, and it's no coincidence that the film emerged during the headiest days of the Bush administration. Following the attacks of September 11th, Americans were afraid, and the government - like the government of this book - was all too willing to harness that fear in exchange for control. People were told to watch what they say about the President, the government or the troops. Television pundits and spokespeople demanded that criticism be shut down, and that those who disagreed with what the country was doing were branded traitors.
Fortunately, we got through those frightened times, but even today, those who would stay in power use fear to keep people in line. Fear of death, fear of immigrants, fear of gays - fear of The Other - are the first weapons they use to command obedience from their citizenry.
And most people fall in line very easily. It's not surprising, really. Most people, when they're afraid, look to someone to take care of them, to protect them and to tell them what to do. It's a natural impulse, a natural need of human beings. But V exhorts us to move past that. He reminds us that, in a quote from the film, “People should not be afraid of their governments - governments should be afraid of their people.” While our government never reached the depths of the one in this book, it is something that all citizens of all countries should remember.
The book is also about personal freedom. We are all of us prisoners, really - prisoners of our societies and prisoners of ourselves. We are held down by our preconceptions , our doubts and our illusions; our own minds and our beliefs about what others expect of us are what keep us locked into a prison whose bars we cannot even see. V freed himself from his own literal and spiritual confinement to go from prisoner to a societal force, bursting free in an explosion of flame and destruction. He meets a young woman, Evey Hammond, and brings her into his world - partly to be his accomplice, but also to show her how to be free. Her freedom comes at a cost too, enduring the greatest nightmare of a citizen of a fascist society. But she survives, and finds her freedom in the rain and the dark.
The lesson that V teaches us, whether as individuals or societies, is twofold: we hold ourselves prisoner, and there is no more vicious or cruel jailer than ourselves. And that freedom is frightening - it is wild and uncontrolled, and never comes without a price. But that price is well worth paying.
To be honest, it took me a long time to finally enjoy this book. When it came out originally, I was big into super-hero books, and V struck me as just goofy. Why would someone wear such a dumb mask? I thought. And that hat? The cloak is okay, but.... Of course, I knew nothing of Guy Fawkes at the time, so perhaps my ignorance of British history held me back, but still, I was very impatient with it. Also, the art was much rougher and darker than I was used to. The usual four-color palette and clean inks of super-hero comics are not to be found in this book. Instead there are washes of pale purple and yellow and green, with heavy inks and faces full of sorrow and pain.
In other words, it was not what I expected from a comic, and so I gave it a wide berth. And that was probably for the best, since I think that having a better idea of politics and society makes the story that much more interesting. It's a complex and multi-leveled tale that deserves a thoughtful read, and asks a lot from its reader, and if you expect to get through it without doing some thinking of your own, then you'll be sorely disappointed.
That is, however, the mark of a great work - does it make you think? Does it come back to you later, when you're watching the news or reading the newspaper? When you see a story about the pervasiveness of security cameras and think, "I wish V were here," then Alan Moore and David Lloyd have truly done their jobs.
V isn't the hero we expect from comics. He isn't the hero we'd necessarily want, either. But a person like V is necessary sometimes - someone who values freedom above all else. Let us hope that we never need him.
-------------------------------------------
"Noise is relative to the silence preceding it. The more absolute the hush, the more shocking the thunderclap.
Our masters have not heard the people's voice for generations, Evey... and it is much, much louder than they care to remember."
- V, V for Vendetta
-------------------------------------------