I think I want one!
What's Up, Pussycat? Whoa!
By SUSAN SAULNY
Published: May 12, 2005
DARJEERLING and Bunnicula are two kittens who prefer shrimp cocktails and steak frites to pet food. They sleep on Burberry beds in their Greenwich Village apartment and wore matching crystal-studded collars until a few weeks ago, when they chewed off all the stones.
Ruth Fremson/The New York Times
ON THE PROWL: Savannahs, like this one in Greenwich Village, are illegal in New York.
Forum: Pets
Ruth Fremson/The New York Times
CONTRABAND CAT: Darjeeling out for a stroll in Greenwich Village.
They live a life of luxury, to be sure, but it is life on the lam.
They are outlawed in New York City, members of a new designer breed growing in popularity called the Savannah, an offspring of a wildcat - the African serval - and the domestic house cat.
"If I have to move to New Jersey to keep these cats, I will," said their owner, a 29-year-old hedge fund analyst who equates life in downtown Manhattan with life itself. "That's how much I love them," she said, speaking only on the condition of anonymity.
The cats - which can cost from $4,000 to $10,000 - are visually striking with their long necks and oversized ears, and they can be intimidating. They look like little leopards and grow to more than twice the size of normal cats. They love to leap and splash in water, and they don't mind taking long walks on a leash. Some people describe them as dogs in cats' bodies.
"More than ever, everyone's been calling me about the Savannah, and I'm like, 'What's going on?' " said Bash Dibra, an animal trainer in New York whose sessions, at $300 to $500 an hour, are often the last resort for people who cannot control their Savannahs.
Taking care of them on the sly - as New Yorkers must - can be tricky. Across the country, however, the Savannah is not always illegal: a hodgepodge of city and county regulations and state laws govern pets that are part wild.
In New York authorities do not scour the streets for such pets. Owners are often in hiding from their neighbors who might report them. For instance Darjeerling and Bunnicula rarely appear outdoors in the light of day. In an apartment on the Upper East Side, another Savannah named Tiger is tended by the household help in the middle of the night. And Kara LoDolce, who recently moved to a new town on Long Island with her Savannah, Mazi, will not even tell her friends where she lives.
"It's hard to have, hard to keep," said Mr. Dibra, who calls that part of the Savannah's appeal. It makes it "more mystical to own," he said.
New York City banned ownership of any wild or part-wild animals long ago. The state followed suit in 2004. Bethany Schumann, an aide to Assemblyman Paul D. Tonko, a Democrat from Amsterdam, who sponsored the state law, said her office had heard from hundreds of angry cat owners for and against the Savannah in the last couple of years.
"For whatever reason, these cats are cats many people would like to have," she said. "There is some sort of wow factor to the 35-pound cat in your Manhattan apartment."
But they come with too many unknowns, she added. "We have no idea what this cat's habitat should be," Ms. Shumann said.
The cats are growing in popularity elsewhere in the country too. It is hard to estimate exactly how many Savannahs are kept as pets. Their numbers are surely small compared with the average cat. But animal trainers, veterinarians and pet-business owners say they are seeing the Savannah more frequently, while they were rare five years ago.
In Chicago, Cynthia A. King, a Savannah owner and breeder, said: "I had to wait two years to get my kittens, and I had cash I was waving in the air. For a first-generation pet, we're talking a $5,000 minimum expenditure. That's how popular they are."
Julian Robertson, a breeder in Reidsville, N.C., said: "We've shipped them to Alaska, we've shipped them to Austria. You name it, and we've shipped them. We can't keep enough of them."
But owners are increasingly worried about restrictions. Chicago recently considered a wide-ranging ban on exotic pets. So far the proposed law has languished in a City Council committee for more than a year, and its future is unclear. Massachusetts and Georgia, like New York, have strict bans against pets like the Savannah, while other states like Illinois and Arizona have restrictions but do not completely prohibit the animal. Some states require owners to obtain permits for part-wild pets. Others require nothing.
We are one of the stricter states because we are one of the most densely populated states," said Dr. Thomas French, the assistant director of the Massachusetts Division of Fisheries and Wildlife. "Any time you get a lot of people in close proximity to untrustworthy animals, it causes conflict. Sometimes the conflict is no more than a neighbor being frightened, but that is still conflict."
Forum: Pets
"We don't cater to people's fears," he said, "but we do try to regulate what we think is a public health threat."
The United States Department of Agriculture is planning a two-day forum later this month in Kansas City, Mo., to hear how state regulators are coping with nontraditional pets. The department's Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service is calling the meeting because it believes that nontraditional pets have created "an entirely new set of challenges" for federal and state authorities, according to the invitation for the event.
The first Savannahs were bred in the early 1980's, and named for the grasslands that are the natural habitat of their ancestor, the African serval. Female Savannahs cost up to $10,000 because they can reproduce. The males sell anywhere from $4,000 to $8,000.
None of the authorities contacted could cite any dangerous incidents involving a Savannah. The same is not true for the African serval. Kim Haddad, a veterinarian and manager of the Captive Wild Animal Protection Coalition, a consortium of zoo professionals, sanctuary operators and animal rights groups in San Carlos, Calif., noted two serval attacks on children in the last four years.
The popularity of cat breeds rises and falls. The Savannahs are said to be gaining on the Bengal, a cross between the Asian leopard cat and a domestic cat, as the country's top exotic cat. "Bengals were the rage for a long time, but then people wanted something bigger," said Joyce Sroufe, a cat breeder in Ponca City, Okla., who was a pioneering force for the Savannahs. "People are really in awe of the way the kitty behaves, much like a dog."
Savannah owners form an odd sort of community, with most keeping a very low profile while others are highly vocal about what they consider a tremendous wrong being inflicted on them simply for loving exotic pets.
Mazi's owner, Ms. LoDolce, is crusading against New York lawmakers, charging that the exotic pets law is unconstitutional in regard to Savannah cats. It allows an exception for hybrid pets that are five generations removed from wild blood. Ms. LoDolce and others argue that there is no scientific way to test a cat for such a thing, making the law unenforceable.
The law also allows owners to keep the illegal pets they already have, if they register the animals with the state. But even that option is rejected by many Savannah owners as a burden that is intrusive.
"There's a level of paranoia about these cats that's unbelievable," Ms. LoDolce said.
Another Savannah owner, Ronni Bennett, who lives in Greenwich Village, said that she does not approve of crossbreeds or wild hybrids, but that she wanted her cat anyway. "That is one of the contradictions of my life," she said. " I don't really approve of what I've done, but the beauty takes my breath away."
That's not the way State Senator Carl L. Marcellino of Syosset, N.Y., sees it. Mr. Marcellino, the Senate sponsor of the state's exotic pet law, objects to the Savannah cat as something alien to the animal universe.
"Breeders are creating animals for commercial purposes that would never exist in the natural world," he said. "These hybrid species are threats to the environment and potentially to the families who think they are buying a family pet and could be purchasing a wild animal."
The Savannah cat has caused a stir about what makes an acceptable pet even among the largest and best known cat enthusiast groups.
"I'm told they're very loving, but I'm not sure I believe it," said Carol Barbee, the president of the American Cat Fanciers Association, which does not recognize the Savannah in its official registry. "We do not want to support designer breeds for the fad pet market."
Some Savannah owners are fighting for their rights with ammunition from another group, the International Cat Association, which does recognize the Savannah as a breed.
"They are the sweetest most gorgeous things you've ever seen," said Leslie Bowers, the association's business manager. Dr. Carolyn McDaniel, a consultant with the Cornell Feline Health Center, said that while Savannahs are popular across the country, she has noticed that they have become particularly alluring to city dwellers. "It's amazing to me that apartment dwellers are frequently the owners of these large semiwild cats," she said.
"I think they're beautiful," Dr. McDaniel added, but "I'll watch them on the nature channel."
By SUSAN SAULNY
Published: May 12, 2005
DARJEERLING and Bunnicula are two kittens who prefer shrimp cocktails and steak frites to pet food. They sleep on Burberry beds in their Greenwich Village apartment and wore matching crystal-studded collars until a few weeks ago, when they chewed off all the stones.
Ruth Fremson/The New York Times
ON THE PROWL: Savannahs, like this one in Greenwich Village, are illegal in New York.
Forum: Pets
Ruth Fremson/The New York Times
CONTRABAND CAT: Darjeeling out for a stroll in Greenwich Village.
They live a life of luxury, to be sure, but it is life on the lam.
They are outlawed in New York City, members of a new designer breed growing in popularity called the Savannah, an offspring of a wildcat - the African serval - and the domestic house cat.
"If I have to move to New Jersey to keep these cats, I will," said their owner, a 29-year-old hedge fund analyst who equates life in downtown Manhattan with life itself. "That's how much I love them," she said, speaking only on the condition of anonymity.
The cats - which can cost from $4,000 to $10,000 - are visually striking with their long necks and oversized ears, and they can be intimidating. They look like little leopards and grow to more than twice the size of normal cats. They love to leap and splash in water, and they don't mind taking long walks on a leash. Some people describe them as dogs in cats' bodies.
"More than ever, everyone's been calling me about the Savannah, and I'm like, 'What's going on?' " said Bash Dibra, an animal trainer in New York whose sessions, at $300 to $500 an hour, are often the last resort for people who cannot control their Savannahs.
Taking care of them on the sly - as New Yorkers must - can be tricky. Across the country, however, the Savannah is not always illegal: a hodgepodge of city and county regulations and state laws govern pets that are part wild.
In New York authorities do not scour the streets for such pets. Owners are often in hiding from their neighbors who might report them. For instance Darjeerling and Bunnicula rarely appear outdoors in the light of day. In an apartment on the Upper East Side, another Savannah named Tiger is tended by the household help in the middle of the night. And Kara LoDolce, who recently moved to a new town on Long Island with her Savannah, Mazi, will not even tell her friends where she lives.
"It's hard to have, hard to keep," said Mr. Dibra, who calls that part of the Savannah's appeal. It makes it "more mystical to own," he said.
New York City banned ownership of any wild or part-wild animals long ago. The state followed suit in 2004. Bethany Schumann, an aide to Assemblyman Paul D. Tonko, a Democrat from Amsterdam, who sponsored the state law, said her office had heard from hundreds of angry cat owners for and against the Savannah in the last couple of years.
"For whatever reason, these cats are cats many people would like to have," she said. "There is some sort of wow factor to the 35-pound cat in your Manhattan apartment."
But they come with too many unknowns, she added. "We have no idea what this cat's habitat should be," Ms. Shumann said.
The cats are growing in popularity elsewhere in the country too. It is hard to estimate exactly how many Savannahs are kept as pets. Their numbers are surely small compared with the average cat. But animal trainers, veterinarians and pet-business owners say they are seeing the Savannah more frequently, while they were rare five years ago.
In Chicago, Cynthia A. King, a Savannah owner and breeder, said: "I had to wait two years to get my kittens, and I had cash I was waving in the air. For a first-generation pet, we're talking a $5,000 minimum expenditure. That's how popular they are."
Julian Robertson, a breeder in Reidsville, N.C., said: "We've shipped them to Alaska, we've shipped them to Austria. You name it, and we've shipped them. We can't keep enough of them."
But owners are increasingly worried about restrictions. Chicago recently considered a wide-ranging ban on exotic pets. So far the proposed law has languished in a City Council committee for more than a year, and its future is unclear. Massachusetts and Georgia, like New York, have strict bans against pets like the Savannah, while other states like Illinois and Arizona have restrictions but do not completely prohibit the animal. Some states require owners to obtain permits for part-wild pets. Others require nothing.
We are one of the stricter states because we are one of the most densely populated states," said Dr. Thomas French, the assistant director of the Massachusetts Division of Fisheries and Wildlife. "Any time you get a lot of people in close proximity to untrustworthy animals, it causes conflict. Sometimes the conflict is no more than a neighbor being frightened, but that is still conflict."
Forum: Pets
"We don't cater to people's fears," he said, "but we do try to regulate what we think is a public health threat."
The United States Department of Agriculture is planning a two-day forum later this month in Kansas City, Mo., to hear how state regulators are coping with nontraditional pets. The department's Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service is calling the meeting because it believes that nontraditional pets have created "an entirely new set of challenges" for federal and state authorities, according to the invitation for the event.
The first Savannahs were bred in the early 1980's, and named for the grasslands that are the natural habitat of their ancestor, the African serval. Female Savannahs cost up to $10,000 because they can reproduce. The males sell anywhere from $4,000 to $8,000.
None of the authorities contacted could cite any dangerous incidents involving a Savannah. The same is not true for the African serval. Kim Haddad, a veterinarian and manager of the Captive Wild Animal Protection Coalition, a consortium of zoo professionals, sanctuary operators and animal rights groups in San Carlos, Calif., noted two serval attacks on children in the last four years.
The popularity of cat breeds rises and falls. The Savannahs are said to be gaining on the Bengal, a cross between the Asian leopard cat and a domestic cat, as the country's top exotic cat. "Bengals were the rage for a long time, but then people wanted something bigger," said Joyce Sroufe, a cat breeder in Ponca City, Okla., who was a pioneering force for the Savannahs. "People are really in awe of the way the kitty behaves, much like a dog."
Savannah owners form an odd sort of community, with most keeping a very low profile while others are highly vocal about what they consider a tremendous wrong being inflicted on them simply for loving exotic pets.
Mazi's owner, Ms. LoDolce, is crusading against New York lawmakers, charging that the exotic pets law is unconstitutional in regard to Savannah cats. It allows an exception for hybrid pets that are five generations removed from wild blood. Ms. LoDolce and others argue that there is no scientific way to test a cat for such a thing, making the law unenforceable.
The law also allows owners to keep the illegal pets they already have, if they register the animals with the state. But even that option is rejected by many Savannah owners as a burden that is intrusive.
"There's a level of paranoia about these cats that's unbelievable," Ms. LoDolce said.
Another Savannah owner, Ronni Bennett, who lives in Greenwich Village, said that she does not approve of crossbreeds or wild hybrids, but that she wanted her cat anyway. "That is one of the contradictions of my life," she said. " I don't really approve of what I've done, but the beauty takes my breath away."
That's not the way State Senator Carl L. Marcellino of Syosset, N.Y., sees it. Mr. Marcellino, the Senate sponsor of the state's exotic pet law, objects to the Savannah cat as something alien to the animal universe.
"Breeders are creating animals for commercial purposes that would never exist in the natural world," he said. "These hybrid species are threats to the environment and potentially to the families who think they are buying a family pet and could be purchasing a wild animal."
The Savannah cat has caused a stir about what makes an acceptable pet even among the largest and best known cat enthusiast groups.
"I'm told they're very loving, but I'm not sure I believe it," said Carol Barbee, the president of the American Cat Fanciers Association, which does not recognize the Savannah in its official registry. "We do not want to support designer breeds for the fad pet market."
Some Savannah owners are fighting for their rights with ammunition from another group, the International Cat Association, which does recognize the Savannah as a breed.
"They are the sweetest most gorgeous things you've ever seen," said Leslie Bowers, the association's business manager. Dr. Carolyn McDaniel, a consultant with the Cornell Feline Health Center, said that while Savannahs are popular across the country, she has noticed that they have become particularly alluring to city dwellers. "It's amazing to me that apartment dwellers are frequently the owners of these large semiwild cats," she said.
"I think they're beautiful," Dr. McDaniel added, but "I'll watch them on the nature channel."