Round #8 - Challenge #5 - Results
I had a wonderful voting turn out. Thanks to everyone who voted!! The final challenge will be posted shortly!
Sadly we are saying goodbye to 1 icon maker tonight:
by whatever_freak with 7 votes
Sorry to see you eliminated!! Congrats on placing in 3rd! I'll make you a banner for it soon.
Community's Choice:
by tarachen with 6 votes.
Jamie's Choice:
by whatever_freak. I thought it was really cute & colored well.
Tally
I am not like most LIMS mods who count the total of negative and positive together to determined who gets boots. It's math and I don't do it well. So therefore you are eliminated by the number of negative votes only. - indicts negative, + indicts positive. In case you are wondering I am doing the comments like this from now on to protect voter's identities. Remember these are here so that you can improve, not to be insults.
#1. -2, +3
#2. -2, +6
#3. -7, +2
Negative votes
#1. the coloring is mute and the cropping is unoriginal, also the text makes it that much more depressing.
the icon is a bit blurry.
#2. the picture is so small i cant see their faces.
the texture overpowers the subjects although the icon is still very nice.
#3. cropping is unremarkable and the colouring is a bit overpowering.
over saturated (too greenish blue with red/pink highlights).
not much done besides colouring (which is oddly greenish-red in some places).
the crop boxes in the twins and leaves no room for movement plus the coloring used makes their eyes a bit too blue.
it's pretty, but a little bit too blue and blurry.
too much coloring.
Unoriginal crop & the icon is a tiny bit blurry around Mk's face. Good color though!.
Positive votes
#1. i love the use of texture.
nice use of repeating background text.
nice use of text.
#2.
crop and texture work beautifully together.
great crop and great use of textures; overall a creative icon.
it was a tough choice, but i like the subtleness of this one more.
coloring and textures are perfect!
Amazing use of texture creating a great composition.
the colors are nice and i like the brush added, makes it very special (gotta say 2 and 3 are both fantastic so it was hard to choose).
#3. the coloring is very nicely done.
its cute!
Sadly we are saying goodbye to 1 icon maker tonight:
by whatever_freak with 7 votes
Sorry to see you eliminated!! Congrats on placing in 3rd! I'll make you a banner for it soon.
Community's Choice:
by tarachen with 6 votes.
Jamie's Choice:
by whatever_freak. I thought it was really cute & colored well.
Tally
I am not like most LIMS mods who count the total of negative and positive together to determined who gets boots. It's math and I don't do it well. So therefore you are eliminated by the number of negative votes only. - indicts negative, + indicts positive. In case you are wondering I am doing the comments like this from now on to protect voter's identities. Remember these are here so that you can improve, not to be insults.
#1. -2, +3
#2. -2, +6
#3. -7, +2
Negative votes
#1. the coloring is mute and the cropping is unoriginal, also the text makes it that much more depressing.
the icon is a bit blurry.
#2. the picture is so small i cant see their faces.
the texture overpowers the subjects although the icon is still very nice.
#3. cropping is unremarkable and the colouring is a bit overpowering.
over saturated (too greenish blue with red/pink highlights).
not much done besides colouring (which is oddly greenish-red in some places).
the crop boxes in the twins and leaves no room for movement plus the coloring used makes their eyes a bit too blue.
it's pretty, but a little bit too blue and blurry.
too much coloring.
Unoriginal crop & the icon is a tiny bit blurry around Mk's face. Good color though!.
Positive votes
#1. i love the use of texture.
nice use of repeating background text.
nice use of text.
#2.
crop and texture work beautifully together.
great crop and great use of textures; overall a creative icon.
it was a tough choice, but i like the subtleness of this one more.
coloring and textures are perfect!
Amazing use of texture creating a great composition.
the colors are nice and i like the brush added, makes it very special (gotta say 2 and 3 are both fantastic so it was hard to choose).
#3. the coloring is very nicely done.
its cute!