Renting solar panels: Can anyone find the catch? Is there one?

Dec 29, 2007 22:19


This sounds completely awesome. I learned about it at the Troy Farmer's Market this morning. It's basically a long-term leased solar power system for your home. The upfront cost is a $500 security deposit. You lock in a monthly rental rate for the equipment based on the current price of electricity now, and it doesn't go up for 25 years. It's tied ( Read more... )

house, money, environment

Leave a comment

tenner December 30 2007, 16:54:26 UTC
This seems very cool; pallagia and I were talking about photovoltaics yesterday morning and then you go ahead and post this last night. Brilliant.

Our exact problem is that we would absolutely love to set up a PV system, but we can't afford the up-front costs. We have a huge sloped roof facing the south and above the treeline so I think we could probably generate enough power for the rest of the neighborhood. We're perfect candidates for this.

Let us know what you find!

Reply

bratling December 31 2007, 00:48:03 UTC
Bhakti and I are also pretty intrigued. Well, she's excited, I'm intrigued. I need to finish reading through the site but it may be worth it to us to get in line now. We're not planning on going anywhere for a while, and we have a big flat roof that gets a lot of sun throughout the day.

Miriam, thanks for bringing this to our attention...

Reply

chezjake December 31 2007, 02:32:05 UTC
One thing I see that you should keep in mind is that they will only install a system that meets your *average* requirements.

Here's the quote: Citizenrē guarantees that your REnU is designed to produce as close to your average electricity needs as possible, given the characteristics of your house and location.You need to read this as they are *not* going to install a system that produces more than your average need, so you can't ever expect to have any significant income from selling power to the grid. In fact, you need to check your own state's regulations on this, because some states basically allow you to earn credit toward your electric utility bill, but you won't get paid anything for any excess over your own total usage ( ... )

Reply

miriamjoyce December 31 2007, 03:03:31 UTC

It was my understanding that they weren't going to install a larger system than your needs specifically because you're not likely by law to be able to earn money that way so it wouldn't be worth it for you. The calendar year provision would suck though--we should check NY's laws, but I don't think it has that.

Also though, the expected savings to be generated is not from generating extra power above what you use, it's from having fixed costs rather than rising costs like everyone else. The utility intertie is more for not having to have batteries in your basement, not for generating income. (Again, yes, if you lose credits on Jan. 1st that wouldn't work.)

Reply

bratling December 31 2007, 03:10:13 UTC
not having to have batteries in your basement

if i were going the PV route i'd want to investigate this. we aren't home during most days to use the power, so all the PV would be powering would be a computer server in the basement and the clocks in the stove and microwave. getting credit from the grid would be key to making this pay off.

even long term, if i couldn't get credit from the grid then i'd still end up paying the grid for nighttime power use (lights, music, several computers). which is where batteries come into the picture... without grid-credit or batteries, i just don't see how it can work out well for people who aren't home during the day.

that said, i'm pretty sure MA isn't one of the screw-you states. but i'll have to check and make sure the rules haven't changed since my dad worked at the power company a decade back. under Romney, any sort of anti-consumer idiocy is not only possible but probable.

Reply

miriamjoyce December 31 2007, 03:14:44 UTC

Yeah, grid credit is definitely essential to making this all work, which is why they're only operating in states with net metering laws. I'm looking into NY's. Let us know what you find about MA's.

Reply

bratling December 31 2007, 03:40:56 UTC
some poking around found me this guidebook, which isn't written for consumers but does have some key information about putting power back into the grid:

http://www.mass.gov/Eoca/docs/doer/pub_info/guidebook.pdf

from page 29:
The net metering regulations, 220 CMR 11.04, allow for a distribution company's customer with a QF or OSGF of 60 kW or less to run the meter backward and receive a credit, equal to the arithmetic average of the ISO power exchange price in the previous month, in any month that the customer generates more electricity than it consumes. The credit appears on the customer's next bill, unless a customer requests a check for the credit ( ... )

Reply

miriamjoyce December 31 2007, 03:45:41 UTC

Lucky you! (See my comment to Jake on NY's).

Reply

chezjake December 31 2007, 03:20:45 UTC
Hmmm. No battery storage at all means that even your summer power generation will get you less credits toward winter, since you'll be having to use the grid for all your after sundown power use year round.

BTW, there are some changes in the works for NY net metering, but I don't think they'll change much for homeowners.
http://www.timesunion.com/AspStories/story.asp?storyID=650243

Reply

miriamjoyce December 31 2007, 03:32:53 UTC

It should work out the same: either you store your power and don't sell or buy anything to/from the grid, or you get credit during the day and use at night.

except that batteries are expensive and need replacing. very very few people in urban contexts do solar without a utility intertie, even if they're buying the systems themselves.

Reply

miriamjoyce December 31 2007, 03:29:13 UTC

Interesting. So here's how New York works:

If you have generated more than you used in a given month you get a credit on your next month's bill based on the retail rate. If at the end of the year you still have a credit, the utility pays you cash for any remaining credit--but at their avoided cost, which is lower than retail rate. Not nearly as bad as losing it, but not ideal.

It would be nice if you could apply your credit to your connection fee or even the gas portion of your bill. Then you would have any building up over the summer anyway. I doubt that's how it works, although that is a legitimate way to read the law.

http://www.dsireusa.org/documents/Incentives/NY05R.htm

Reply

miriamjoyce December 31 2007, 03:11:26 UTC

Yay! We did grt in line while we're thinking it through, since you don't have to commit until you see the actual system design and get the monthly rate.

Reply

bratling December 31 2007, 03:28:03 UTC
i saw the form but it looked like in Step 3 they were going to ask for money. is this not the case?

Reply

miriamjoyce December 31 2007, 03:30:38 UTC
It is not the case. Security deposit only comes after the site visit and you see the design and learn how much it will generate, etc.

Reply

bratling December 31 2007, 03:53:00 UTC
i'm in line now. i think. :)

Reply


Leave a comment

Up